Hacker News Reader

Comment by minikites | Hacker News Reader

At this point, anyone who signs up for a new Google service is a sucker with no sense of pattern recognition.

Reading comments like this makes me realize why people get so angry at Kickstarter products where they fail at delivering stuff.

You know what Google's experimental stuff is like. You can choose not to use it because you like stability.

But there are lots of us who like the novelty and stuff. So you're not made of early adopter material. Don't early adopt.

There's a difference between that and what Google does. Look at how many products on https://killedbygoogle.com/ that were several years old, e.g. AngularJS (11 years). And I'm sure many of us remember Google Reader.

To be fair AngularJS has a successor in Angular and thus is a bad example. I think it is fine to drop it after 14 years of support (which is almost ridiculously long in JS-time)

Omg, it also turns out that the Linux foundation killed Linux 3.0! How dare companies stop supporting old versions of their software!

I think if these projects were branded as Google Beta, or under Google Labs, people would be less disappointed when they get shut down.

I agree wholly here. Google needs to be much more upfront when floating experiments. It's good that they do, but the signaling needs to be better. Or even different branding altogether. It would go a long way to help their image.

Gmail was in "beta" for years and years, I don't think this would actually solve anything.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com