I don't know why you say I champion the BSD license, I only used it as an example. I have never used the BSD license, for the very reasons you just stated - it is at odds with what I want the program's code to be used for.
These terms are not contradictory. Anyone can use and distribute the code for whatever purpose, and any changes made to the code must be made available to the open source community, just like the GPL, except now only that part of the program must be released as source code, and the unrelated portions of the program are free to remain proprietary. This isn't incompatible, and it isn't the GPL.