My experience is consumers join as many daily deal sites as they want to. They are not loyal to one. The only cost of joining one more is an email a day.
Local deal sites are by defn focused on many independent local market. Their key promo channel is email to signed up users, since most people won't go to a website to look at deals everyday. What's the barrier to entry for another site - getting the same user signed up?
There will certainly be consolidation, there will be two or three local deals sites left over. They will certainly not enjoy the margins GroupOn currently commands.