https://twitter.com/dmetaxak/status/1362856231212212224
Google recently added a feature allowing users to search for "Black-owned businesses near you". They're advertising it all over the place (see below).
I've also already started hearing from Black-owned businesses I follow that they're seeing an influx of racist fake reviews...
BLK MKT Vintage, for instance, got over 30 new, clearly fake reviews in 24 hours (e.g., calling them "a store that promotes segregation", saying their items were "broken" and "covered in dead cockroaches").
And if you look at the users writing those reviews...
The users leaving those fraudulent 1-star reviews for this business are also leaving 1-star reviews on dozens of other Black-owned businesses.
All this while Google pays for PR lauding this new feature.
We need to ask: is it always a good idea to make marginalized groups more visible? Whom does it benefit?
Have such companies thought through the consequences for those they're "helping"? Was this done at the direction of those groups or paternalistically on behalf of?
This is yet another example of why app features cannot and should not replace community networks and mutual aid.
Technosolutionism, the white savior complex, and paternalism towards marginalized groups lead to selfish PR efforts that actively harm those they ostensibly "help".