Sure you can try to have a proper discussion online, but too many people want to DESTROY people with FACTS and LOGIC. Or in practice ad hominems, false equivalencies, and just about every other fallacy in the book. If a topic is remotely controversial it's just about impossible to have a discussion that would make any sense at all.
HN is really the only place I even bother to write a comment, on the whole people seem to be at least have a somewhat charitable interpretation of other people's comments.