This is what makes newer ThinkPad keyboard layouts great at least in terms of arrow keys - the useless icon keys from the GP's posted image are now PgUp/PgDown, meaning you can access at least two out of the four without annoying two-handed operation. Home/End can still be bound to arrow keys plus modifier, but even there it's nice to have a dedicated key available.
Basically, full-size arrow keys are what really makes the difference, and at that point you could get the best of both worlds anyway.
(Let's not talk about other recent/misguided ThinkPad keyboard developments though.)