Can anyone compare this to Google's two-factor authentication using the Authenticator App? The app is open source (http://code.google.com/p/google-authenticator/) and the private key(correct?) is provided via a QR scan.
with secureid the secret key is fixed in the hardware (and RSA keep a copy of the key), whereas with Google authenticator you can generate and input the key yourself, so that Google never sees it.
I can confirm that. The app doesn't require any permissions. I rebooted my phone while in flight mode and the Google login via Authenticator code works as expected.
Google still needs to know the secret. All authenticators are based on a shared secret model, so the same possible attack vector that bit RSA.