Hacker News Reader

Hi,

Congratulations with your launch.

Question: must an end user (web site visitor) do a (Github or other) login? Or can they simply leave a comment?

Hey thank you very much. No login needed for submitting an issue. However follow up is handled differently:

Public repos: the reporter is given the link on successful submission, so to communicate further a GitHub account is required

Private repos: the reporter needs to supply an email (not shared with repo) which will be held by Issue Embed and handle communication from the issue to email (and visa-versa)

You can try a demo here: https://issueembed.dev/

Edit: formatting

I gave the reporting a try, and I like the flow in the demo (which is for a Public repo); easy to use.

For a private repo, I would probably also want people to be able to leave anonymous replies (to get 'as much feedback as possible'), but that's just my n=1 opinion.

Good luck.

Thanks for the feedback, I have been thinking of whether making email optional or allowing the admin to not show it. Your feedback is a noted data point, thank you!

Reply on news.ycombinator.com