It also has the downside that it doesn't match what is being shown: when I hit * on "overview" it highlights both "overview" and "Overview" (I have highlight search enabled), but cgn replaces only one of them. When the cursor is on Overview and I run "*cgnexample<esc>..." it will skip all the "Overview"s and only replace "overview".
But perhaps it's a bug in Vim since it works when I run * on the lowercase variant.