In Defense of Substack
taibbi.substack.com
taibbi.substack.com
Roberts' defense of mainstream media - the idea that they are pinnacles of trust and ethics - is threadbare at this point. She's fantasizing about an industry culture that doesn't exist (and may never have), demonstrably.
Spending $50/yr on Taibbi and/or Greenwald is some of the best investment you can do in journalism today.
EDIT: clarity
>The answer connects to one of the primary reasons audiences are moving to places like Substack: the perception that traditional news outlets have become tools of the very corporate and political interests they’re supposed to be overseeing.
Ah, the Ted Cruz defense - people think this thing, so let's pretend it's true. Nevermind the fact the only reason they think it's true is because I told them it's true.
I think at the end of the day, Taibbi is making a rather unconvincing argument that you can write a slanted, cherry picked article to back your own political bent and that's still objective journalism because the cherry picked facts are wrong. Which just seems like an absurd failure to get to grips with a world in which climate change is a debate and people spent decades dying of cancer because of manufactured "objective facts" about smoking.
Your comment about objectivity in scare quotes, are you arguing there is no objectivity to seek out? Or are you pointing out that facts can be false? It's unclear why you put that in quotation marks.
Is that really the only reason? Could things such as major networks hiring ex-CIA personnel [1] contribute to that impression? Or maybe Reuters and the BBC acting as an arm of the UK foreign office [2]?
Edit: And of course the article itself cites some compelling reasons in the very next paragraph.
[1] https://dailycaller.com/2019/08/23/cnn-msnbc-15-spooks-mccab...
[2] https://thegrayzone.com/2021/02/20/reuters-bbc-uk-foreign-of...
Your second citation is pretty funny, are you really telling me Americans don't trust their media because the UK FCO sponsored pro free media content in Russia?
produce an “attitudinal change in the participants,” promoting a “positive impact” on their “perception of Russia.”
and CNN was full of ex Russian FSB agents, you'd also see it as completely benign.