‘Held to ransom’: Pfizer demands govs gamble with state assets to secure vaccine
thebureauinvestigates.com
thebureauinvestigates.com
Compared to drugs that much be taken continually, vaccines are not lucrative for drug companies. If Pfizer was just money seeking, they'd focus on better Rogaine etc., even in an epidemic, and indeed many drug companies did.
"Pfizer asked for additional indemnity from civil cases, meaning that the company would not be held liable for rare adverse effects or for its own acts of negligence, fraud or malice. This includes those linked to company practices – say, if Pfizer sent the wrong vaccine or made errors during manufacturing."
I cannot imagine what a mindset it takes to think that this is reasonable behaviour.
"Pfizer asked for additional indenmity from civil cases", but did not in e.g. Europe. This implies that Pfizer believes there is additional risk of South American liability cases, or an extended scope of what is considered adverse effects or negligence, etc.
If Pfizer sent the wrong vaccine it would liable in Europe too, so ignore that. You can't explain the difference between two cases using a common factor, you have to look for different factors.
The part in italics is the one I take offense at.
Pfizer was asking for indemnity from things that would be completely their fault and nobody elses.
Indemnity in case of rare adverse effects? Sure, this is a great idea as it might make the difference between getting actually getting vaccines and no company daring to touch vaccine development with a ten-foot pole.
Problems with fraudulent behaviour, negligence or malice on the other hand, that's should be their problem and theirs alone.
It says one clear and attributed thing: "The government believed Pfizer should be liable for any acts of negligence or malice" and that Pfizer disagreed. That is, Pfizer believes that Prizer should be liable for only some acts of negligence or malice. I suspect there's some hyperbole, that the government doesn't really believe that any act of etc., but that the real core of the issue is in that area. What is an act of negligence, what acts of negligence are Pfizer's responsibility? I've heard about people getting fake vaccines in Brazil, that sounds like malice, is it Pfizer's responsibility, did Pfizer take sufficient steps to safeguard against that?
And so my initial assumption is that there are laws or have been some past judgments that Pfizer's lawyers believe pose undue legal risk in that jurisdiction. The article doesn't go into that at all, or into the question of the parties' actual motivations, which I find a bit disappointing, considering that phrase "investigative journalism" on the masthead.