Why Copyright Holders Love iTunes Match And Pirates Hate It
blogs.forbes.com
blogs.forbes.com
The article paints pirates as whiny little children decrying cloud-based streaming services impact on their ability to pirate in much the same impotent way that the music industry 10 years ago decried Napster's impact on their ability to sell CDs for $18.99. All the while ignoring the most basic of details: iTunes is not a streaming service, and the files aren't DRM'ed!
The reality is that "pirate" is not a binary distinction. Painting this as some kind of partisan conflict doesn't serve anybody. What's going on here is that streaming companies like Spotify are finally offering a compelling service that precludes a lot of people's desire to pirate. They've finally figured out how to compete with free. You'd have to travel pretty far and wide to find a pirate who is wringing their hands over this the way the article portrays.
I'm not sure how likely that is to ever actually happen, though. That sounds a little sensationalistic to me.
The only realistic danger with iCloud is the same as with any other cloud service: the company accidentally loses your data. Even in that case there's not much danger. You use iTunes match, you download copies of the matches to your local computer, you back them up.
http://www.nytimes.com/2009/07/18/technology/companies/18ama...
I guess some do have tags that say who ripped them, which would certainly be a tip off. Even then, though, I'm not sure how easily you could automate it to differentiate between tags that indicate piracy and tags that do not.
Of course, that's not the same thing as proving in each case that they really did pirate it, but it'd be a start as a way of building a list of people to look at.
However... I'd suspect it's still illegal, especially if you used bittorrent and thus gave copies out to other people.
That would take a certain amount of coordination with the RIAA and engineering effort on Apple's part to... screw over their paying customers. I don't think it's likely. Nor does Apple have any need to keep the original data on file. They make a match, that's it, job's done.
And when I say "vast majority", I'm referring to the fact that even ripping a mix CD a friend made you or copying an album or 2 off a thumb drive constitutes piracy.
Of course, none of this matters because it's completely impossible for Apple to compile this data reliably.
The aim of suing people is deterrence, but you don't want to deter people that have chosen to pay you, even you're making less money (say, per-track) than you would from a fully-legit customer.
That makes sense because the majority of the $25/year goes to the record companies, who almost surely use the track counts to figure out how to divvy up the money.
This is the first step toward the kind of system that we eventually are going to have to go to, where people pay some kind of fee or tax into a pool, can listen to whatever music they want, and the pool is split among the artists (or the companies the artists sell the rights to) according to what people are actually listening to.
Personally, I'd much rather pay the monthly fee because I listen to much more music than I could ever buy in a conventional manner.
P.S. You can buy music on Spotify as well, but it's not the core idea and I don't know any people that have. Though almost every person I know in Sweden pay for Premium.