I had an app in PlayStore and registered a domain for it. The app didn't take off, never made any money, so I abandoned it and let the domain expire. Now it's listed for $6000!
Generally, when you buy a domain from one of these companies you're dealing with an Afternic salesperson or some other affiliation. These salespeople substantially discount during negotiations.
I recently purchased a very premium domain from Afternic for 25% less than the "sticker price". It sucks having to pay them thousands of dollars but in my view I underpaid for the domain considering the marketability of it.