Be vary once reCAPTCHA asks you to 'spot the fake'.
Be vary once reCAPTCHA asks you to 'spot the fake'.
There, they use two strategies to prevent that:
1) Do not tell the counterfeiters how you discriminate their products from the real ones.
2) Keep the technology you use out of the hands of the counterfeiters.
For this problem, for 2), I think the cat is out of the bag. A with money, keeping tech out of the hands of government-size entities is impossible, but keeping it out of the hands of small players is doable. Here, doing that that would require locking down all computers in the hands of small players to the level iOS does it. Not impossible, but won’t happen overnight, and I don’t think we want to go there.
That leaves 1). That’s a bit at odds with “publish or perish”, but I guess the likes of NSA personnel aren’t in that rat race, so it might be possible for the NSA to provide an online “fake or real?” tool. Of course, that would mean the likes of the NSA could lie when asked whether their fake was real and when asked whether a real image they don’t want to be known as real was real, so we would need multiple, independent such parties.
Otherwise you can just feed whatever video you have in mind into the first stage of that chain you’ve created and say you were there when it happened.
You could then use that internal state as a private key to sign what you want and only keep the corresponding public key and a signed date+time to proof the veracity. The public keys themselves would need to form a blockchain in the traditional sense, so you can verify their integrity without the previous internal states.
If you wanted to go all-in with the verification, you'd probably also want to show something containing the date+time in the video, together with some complicated physical effects that are hard to fake.
Well, just thinking out loud here, but it seems like it might work :D
We can't inherently trust content on the basis of its medium.
It seems like this trivially works better with a centralized database especially since you don't necessarily want to make all of this data public. The general public needs to know that this is a true and accurate photo that hasn't been edited taken on such and such a date. The authorities with a warrant might well need to know that it was taken by a device owned by bob.