Hacker News Reader

Don't "call bullshit" because you can't personally see how to falsify a theory by reading some popularized science articles. There are real papers with math behind these claims, and when you've read them and at least tried to understand the math, then you can call bullshit if you still think so.

View on HN

I am not qualified to do so.

The existence of "real papers with math behind thest claims" is sort of irrelevant. IIT is being proposed as a scientific theory, and the author of TFA claims that IIT is testable, but he has not said anything about actual testing. I cannot judge the math, and I doubt that I could judge a scientific paper describing a test. I'm simply asking: Is there any actualy testing, completed or in progress? TFA did not make such a claim.

Here is a talk in which he mentions specific experiments:

https://youtu.be/LGd8p-GSLgY?t=3512

This is a fairly old talk and if you do a bit more digging I think he has other talks with more experiments.

Thanks, I'll take a look.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com