This sort of tech hubris is all over the tech ecosystem. Folks who believe their startup prowess means they can tackle any medical device with fake-it-till-you-make-it or fail-fast-break-often mentality that often fails in reality.
This sort of tech hubris is all over the tech ecosystem. Folks who believe their startup prowess means they can tackle any medical device with fake-it-till-you-make-it or fail-fast-break-often mentality that often fails in reality.
You can get that for a lot cheaper by traveling and staying in hostels (and also become more well rounded!)
Unless you are going to outproduce China and Vietnam, or are sitting on top of natural resources, the only path is through very skilled population working in high-skill industries.
Its fine if to occasionally pay for some random irrelevant degree, because the cost of uneducated and unproductive population is much higher.
Is it? Imagine if everyone got a 4-year degree - you’d see a dip in productivity (due to less working years per adult), a dip in spending (due to debts), and little productivity gains due to a lack of degree-related work in general.
If you hint to European countries, our universities aren't free at all, we pay them via tax money. Not because "education is a human right" but because that's a more sustainable way to finance the system over the long term and education. Students still have tuition costs though, but of course not as crazy as what you have in the US.
But even in this context universities are reserved to a small number of people, mostly from a wealthier background, and the main reason for students to go to university is to have a "student experience" for a few years, not to learn the actual content. Only a small subset already knows what they want to do when they pick a university.
It was 'run' by the local university, but really was just a package deal they bought from another company.
I gave the university some feedback that they have all the resources at the university to do WAY better than these commercial bootcamps... but the folks involved bought the package deal and are invested in it.
It's sad, the university IMO could do better, if they tried.
Meanwhile the traditional unversity system does work, but is a huge time investment, and the bootcamp system works 'kinda' for some folks ... but fails most IMO.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Innovator%27s_Dilemma
[1] https://www.wired.com/insights/2014/12/understanding-the-inn...
The Facebook widget I wrote was better than being on Facebook and it still fills me with irritation to this day they shitcanned it :-)
[0]https://www.hup.harvard.edu/catalog.php?isbn=9780674089044
Not true for all startups, but increasingly common among the moonshot ones.
They did not break the traditional learning way, but they help a LOT of people, me included, to learn new things.
Could I learn them otherwise, from books and web pages? Sure, but MOOCs help. Did I already attend a university before, so I can guess what MOOC is good and which one is BS? Sure. Are they much less effective than traditional university? Yes. Of course.
But, they are not useless and I am glad they exist, even when they were a bit overhyped in the past.
It was kinda terrifying the idea that we'd run through COVID with hordes of people hooked up to equipment someone came up with by dorking with a 3D printer and some old parts from a vacuum...
It was telling when you didn't see established ventilator makers coming up with their own ad hoc cheap-o designs... much like you didn't see Theranos's competitors make wild claims of their own similar device ... probably for reasons.
I get the point : it's a scary proposition to have 'hacked' solutions to life-and-death medical struggles that have not yet had the time to be properly vetted for errors or bugs..
BUT
1) Most invention came about the same way, with a rough idea of the goal while attempting to use off-the-shelf/available techniques to attain it.
2) The COVID-19 pandemic was out-of-the-ordinary. If truly worst had come to the worst and there was a total break-down of society and medical care, things like 3d printers and old vacuum parts could have been appropriately re-engineered into appropriate medical care devices by those with the professional know-how to do so.
In other words : even if a "3d printed ventilator", for the sake of argument, is a somewhat hazardous idea in the hands of non-professionals, in the event of cataclysmic world-collapse i'd rather there be , even if simple and preliminary, a mediocre set of tools available for professionals to continue their work where possible.
In my opinion the benefit of these designs being available outweighs the disadvantage that Joe-Bob down the road may try to practice self-tracheostomy procedures.
>It was telling when you didn't see established ventilator makers coming up with their own ad hoc cheap-o designs...
the only thing that tells me is that the profit margins weren't 'right enough' to interest large corporate backers into helping -- especially during a time of economic recess and beginning of thrift strategies from the worlds' corporations in expectation of economic problems down the line until the pandemic is over.
The British NHS pay Mercedes F1 for 10,000 units of some whizz-bang CPAP machine during the pandemic.[0] CPAP machines certainly aren't ventilators, but Mercedes F1 certainly isn't an established ventilator maker, either.
https://www.motorsportweek.com/2020/05/08/mercedes-designed-...
"But something is better than nothing" isn't actually true in a lot of medical situations.
People prefer to believe positive news.
The plan required nearly every single smartphone owner in the country to voluntarily use the tracing app, and keep their phone on them at all times in any public setting. Short of that, the results weren't actionable. If the results aren't actionable, people won't opt-in, and the results will be even less actionable.
...and oh yeah it fails in vehicle traffic, or any scenario where people are on the other side of a piece of glass or wall. Hello false flags.
These flaws were obvious before any company wrote a single line of code. It was silicon valley hubris, and a textbook example of a hammer seeing everything as a nail. It predictably failed, and did nothing but distract from actual efforts.
But the worst part is that now all of our smartphones have this insidious BT tracing technology built into the operating system. I am sure Google and FB would LOVE to know all the people we're near, in real time. This technology, brought about under the absurd false pretense of trying to help covid, is here to stay, baked right into the operating system.
In my recollection, it was far less Silicon Valley CEOs, and more open-source hardware enthusiasts crowdsourcing 3D printer designs. Some of them looked as if they could potentially work, but, of course, it also seemed potentially an incredible amount of hubris.
> "Yaron Oren-Pines, who is listed as CEO 0f InCommon in San Jose on both Twitter and LinkedIn, responded to a tweet sent by President Donald Trump on March 27 calling for General Motors and Ford to immediately begin making ventilators. Oren-Pines responded to the president's tweet, saying, "We can supply ICU Ventilators, invasive and non-invasive. Have someone call me URGENT." Oren-Pines has not tweeted since.
Three days later, according to BuzzFeed, New York apparently paid Oren-Pines $69,102,000 for 1,450 ventilators, or $47,656 per ventilator. It was the second-largest purchase made by the state of New York for coronavirus-related medical supplies, according to an analysis by the Albany Times-Union.
To date, New York has received no ventilators from Oren-Pines.
A state official, speaking on condition of anonymity, told BuzzFeed that New York made the deal with Oren-Pines on the recommendation of the White House coronavirus task force. The state has since ended the contract, and is attempting to recover the money."
* https://www.sfgate.com/news/editorspicks/article/NY-paid-Bay...
* https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/us/silicon-valley-engineer-tw...
And there's more Silicon Valley Tech CEO medical device wanna-be pretenders:
* https://abc7.com/california-coronavirus-cases-ventilators-me...
And here's ya boy Elon Musk faking-it and never making-it:
* https://www.sacbee.com/opinion/editorials/article241982586.h...
* https://www.politico.com/states/california/story/2020/04/16/...
This is either sheer incompetence or brazen corruption.
In my experience, it's usually the former, but I'm having trouble believing that this one isn't the latter.
Everything about the White House coronavirus task force has screamed "corruption" the whole way down.
From this article [1], one of several such investigations:
> Many of the volunteers were told to prioritize tips from political allies and associates of President Trump, tracked on a spreadsheet called “V.I.P. Update,”
> Few of the leads, V.I.P. or otherwise, panned out, according to a whistle-blower memo written by one volunteer and sent to the House Oversight Committee.
> ...personal relationships and loyalty are often prized over governmental expertise, and private interests are granted extraordinary access and deference.
1. https://www.nytimes.com/2020/05/05/us/jared-kushner-fema-cor...
Nobody really got a chance to put any new ventilators to the test.
As wary as I am of the situation, we never really saw anyone given a chance to see what those ventilator inventors would have been able to do.
* https://www.sacbee.com/opinion/editorials/article241982586.h...
* https://www.politico.com/states/california/story/2020/04/16/...
He delivered CPAP machines that weren't even of the right type for COVID ventilator use.
> The apparent slight prompted Musk — one of numerous Silicon Valley entrepreneurs with whom the governor has a long-standing relationship — to lash out at the media and implore Newsom in a tweet to “please fix this misunderstanding.” Musk shared screenshots that appeared to show a hospital executive and a Los Angeles County health department official confirming they’d received medical equipment.
> When asked Thursday about the discrepancy, Newsom said he had not yet seen the information Musk shared on Twitter.
> “I was not personally aware of that list,” Newsom said, adding that “I look forward to learning more about where they went and I’m grateful for his support.”
> Later Thursday, Los Angeles County Department of Health Services Director Christina Ghaly said in an emailed statement that Tesla had provided 100 bilevel positive airway pressure units in March — devices that can reduce “the need for certain patients to be placed on mechanical ventilation,” Ghaly said. The company also provided 200 gallons of hand sanitizer and 860 face shields.
From the article linked above:
"According to The Week, after CEO Elon Musk tweeted March 31st that he had “extra FDA-approved ventilators” ready to ship out, Tesla didn’t ship out actual ventilators, it sent machines more closely related to C-PAP devices called BiPAP or B-PAP machines, made by ResMed. C-PAP and Bi-PAP devices are indeed used in hospitals for medical breathing issues, as well as in homes for ailments such as sleep apnea. They use a mask that covers the users entire face or just the nose and mouth, but they are not effective for the critical symptoms of COVID-19, which requires ventilators that include intubation, or the insertion of tubes into the lungs of the patient."
And the hospital seems to think they were useful. And even if it was a complete failure, at least they tried, which is more than most companies.
CPAP is used by the NHS for Covid-19 to try and avoid the need for invasion ventilation, even in the ICU (examples [1], [2]). I was in intensive care for 10 days, and was on CPAP (100% oxygen) for the majority of the time.
[1] https://www.buckshealthcare.nhs.uk/Downloads/AA_COVID_19/COV...
[2] https://www.sign.ac.uk/media/1757/sg_cpap_guidance_version_2...