They support HomeKit and while their own API technically isn't open, it's documented and has libraries to interact with it programmatically.
They support HomeKit and while their own API technically isn't open, it's documented and has libraries to interact with it programmatically.
The downside of Zigbee is that, as a user, there isn't a strong ecosystem of DIY IoT solutions like there is with, for example, the wifi-connected ESP8266/ESP32 chips. And, of course, it requires a hub and some degree of knowledge to set up.
At the moment I'm evaluating launching a small IoT startup/side-business in an underserved market. As much as I love Zigbee, these devices will probably end up being wifi. I'm not an expert in the hardware side of things, and the ability to pay <$1 for an ESP chip that does everything I need off the shelf is great, and I don't want to create a hub or require users to buy a (often $80+) hub just for my set of (<=$5) devices.
Although it'll be wifi-based, I plan to make these guarantees:
- The cloud service (supported by a small yearly subscription) will stay online for at least 1 year after the last device is sold.
- When the service is shut down, its software and hardware will be released under an open source license.
- The subscription fee will never be increased faster than inflation rate.
- 3rd party analytics software won't be used and data will never be shared with 3rd parties (outside from Stripe during checkout). In all cases a minimum amount of data will be collected.
Maybe this'll make my product slightly less likely to appear on the @internetofshit Twitter account[2].
Luckily, as you probably know, you can connect all those different protocols together with homeassistant. So you can use pre-built solutions for some devices and DIY for others and still easily connect them.
It's a really nice standard, I hope it takes off.
Edit: oh and it has already taken off as much as it will, the ZigBee alliance is working on a an ipv6 based standard.
But if you do go Wi-Fi, why use a cloud service at all? Is there a specific reason not to go with mDNS/DNS-SD and handle everything on the local network?
[0] https://www.ikea.com/de/de/p/tradfri-gateway-weiss-40337806/
Do you mean they don't as a matter of manufacturing, or that you have blocked them yourself? (I ask because I am also interested in getting some lights, but would also like them to be local-network-only.)
Typically, manufacturers sell you a "bridge" or "gateway", which is a networked device including such a transceiver. You could isolate this single device from accessing the internet or you could just not rely on any closed option. You can buy a USB Zigbee transceiver for 30 EUR and use it with your PC or a Raspberry Pi.