If anyone believes that RMS is fit for that role, that says a lot about the state of FOSS.
If anyone believes that RMS is fit for that role, that says a lot about the state of FOSS.
Compromise and bringing people together is the slow track to becoming subservient to corporate interests. Mozilla works with people and we end up with an OK browser that is strategically playing second fiddle to Google.
Brave was really quite an eye opener for me as a reminder that a web browser doesn't have to tag along on the path Chrome dictates. Which is ironic given that they use Chrome as a base and Firefox has its own rendering engine.
After that I'm not sure what it's offering. What is the eye opening factor here? In what ways has Brave really taken leadership?
If Google or Apple did the same things Brave did with their cryptocoin donation scheme it would seem incredibly abusive. Also, if Apple promoted that they used local machine learning to develop profiles for optimal ad placement on you, it would only damage their brand.
Brave is attempting to bring about a vision where the user has direct access to the advertising ecosystem. That is offering users a slice of advertising revenue. That is significant. And it is a level of radical that Mozilla/Firefox simply isn't showing.
They are basically acting like the internet is done, Chrome figured it out and they just have to provide the same again but with a different rendering engine and some configuration tweaks. Acceptable, but uninspiring and sort-of pointless. Anyone who cares about having a good web browser jumped ship to Chrome.
And if any of the major browser vendors did the same thing Brave did, it would be a scandal. In that way, Brave's innovation must be that they can fly under the radar.
Yeah, that is what I was pointing to. All that happened without the iPhone being all that different from what was on the market. Other phones made calls, other phones had software.
iPhone really just threw good design, an app store and no keyboard into the mix. We wouldn't know that was revolutionary, market upending levels of change except for being around to see the results.
Embedding crypto into the web browser is a big deal, even if you don't think much the idea. It has implications, it might change how money flows in the web which is quite drastic. It isn't obvious to me why you think the idea is a scandal but each to their own I say.
There's a difference in not compromising one's principles and not compromising in acting like boar towards other human beings.
One can be both highly principled and considerate to others. Human-to-human actions can be civil while one pursues one goals.
We're not in some ancient field of combat where no quarter is asked for, or given, by either side in battle.
Who do you think is going to give quarter on this metaphorical battlefield? Do you mean that people aren't trying to get Stallman imprisoned?
Diversity was never meant to be that everyone was supposed to think the same way, as far as I recall.
People with behavioural disorders need neither be forgiven their transgressions, nor publicly berated in some infantile display of tyranny, but may/should instead be quietly levered out. Competent managers have been doing so for aeons, including with high profile folks displaying problematic habits, like RMS.
I agree with that. I don't call for forgiving RMS, just for proportionate measures to contain his behaviour while not depriving him from his life's work. I believe we went from wrist slaps ("please do not handle your cards inside the conference venue") to mob lynching ("RMS should cease to exist").
Being a member, but not a president, of the FSF board seems like an appropriate middle road to me. And it's up to the rest of the board that reinstated him to keep him contained. In the meantime, anyone else is welcome to: Not invite RMS to their conference. Refuse him registration, if he tries. Give his photo to the security, if needed. That would be proportionate and warranted measures, until RMS provenly gets his act straight. And if he's not ok with that, he's still free to willfully resign.
RMS is a symbol and an ideological leader, traits which are very important for the role and likely much more valuable to the FSF than this person who just left (whom I've never heard of before).
See, for instance, https://www.gnu.org/licenses/why-not-lgpl.html :
> Proprietary software developers, seeking to deny the free competition an important advantage, will try to convince authors not to contribute libraries to the GPL-covered collection. For example, they may appeal to the ego, promising “more users for this library” if we let them use the code in proprietary software products. Popularity is tempting, and it is easy for a library developer to rationalize the idea that boosting the popularity of that one library is what the community needs above all.
If the GNU philosophy were "we're here to code," then that argument would be convincing.
(And indeed there are and were many people taking a "we're here to code" view - DJB, for instance, who insisted that he didn't copyright his software and it didn't need a license and all talk of licensing was a distraction; people who put their software on GitHub without a license; people who use GitHub and other non-free services instead of taking a principled stand against them; etc. Stallman's activism stood in opposition to all of those views.)
Richard Stallman is definitely an “everything is politics” type. If he ever was on the “we’re here to code” side, it was before he ran into the issues that led him to found the FSF, which is also an everything-is-politics organization.
You might prefer an aloof, privileged “we’re here to code” attitude, but projecting that onto Richard Stallman of all people is ludicrous.
That's exactly RMS’s perennial position.
The only difference between him and the most extreme trigger-happy advocate of some specific narrow position on gender or racial politics is the subject area on which Stallman focusses.
Just think if open source activists would refuse to participate in (non-programming) political activities because invite was made with M$ Word.
He created the role. It fits him like a glove, because he created it from his own vision. If you don't think he is fit for the role, then you don't understand what you're talking about.