> I have seen factual claims all over the map on this
Would love to see a counter argument if there is one
> government subsidies and favoritism are all over the place, not just in favor of suburban homeowners.
There are many subsidies, but the magnitudes differ. Note it's not only home ownership subsidies, but zoning and other regulations, preference for building highways and not trains, low gas tax and lack of carbon tax, and many other such things.
The strong towns people also talk about longer and improperly financed pumbling and electrical lines, etc., but I don't know as much about that.
> Which I am completely in favor of doing; I'm quite willing to pay whatever the actual costs are of living where I want to live, and factoring those costs into my choice of where to live.
Great! But watch for big changes if this happens.
> This is still not an argument for forcing everyone to live in densely populated cities.
It doesn't need to be coerced, and properly accounting the externalities alone would make me quite happy too.
But some things like public transit the market just cannot do. The portion value captured is too small a portion --- while the operational costs can break even the capital costs might take > 50 years to recoup --- so that conventional finance says no. And that's not to say it's not worth, but it's a level of "risk" that even for truly great efficiency the private sector won't stomach. Also it is a natural monopoly so it would have to be regulated to death anyways if was privately run, basically defeating the purpose of trying to involve a market.
Also, note I said density not size. If people want to live in a https://media.timeout.com/images/103639693/1024/576/image.jp... in the middle of nowhere and there is a train running to it, that's fine with me.
> Where is that coming from? Certainly not from the references you gave. And if you think cities don't pollute, I don't know where you're getting that from either.
No not those sources but suburbs have far higher energy usage because the inefficiency of the sprawl and large homes, and even if we electrify everything with good power sources, there is tire pollution of electric cars, environment issues from the shear amount of land being taken (e.g. drainage like we saw in Houston during Hurricane Harvey).
--------
Bottom line is suburbs can work, but at great efficiency costs, so you have coordinate globally and fixing all our externalizes, and sacrifice the wealth that would come from greater efficiency in a rather heavy de-growth way, and probably rely on a shrunken population. In other words, if we were to do everything else right, this would be a "luxery" we can maybe get away with the next century.
But if so, what's the point? What's the point of individualist- nuclear-family-ist- vineer of that suburbanization if behind the scenes there is massive collecitivism to enforce everything to need it work? I do hope there is a time after this big mess of unsustainability to have more "ethical luxeries", but I can't imagine suburbanization would be one anyone would want at that point.