I call BS. Do you have a statistic you can cite?
And maybe you should be a bit more thankful to the group of people who ensure you can buy cheap produce in American supermarkets. Among other things...
I call BS. Do you have a statistic you can cite?
And maybe you should be a bit more thankful to the group of people who ensure you can buy cheap produce in American supermarkets. Among other things...
Average cost of a California public school student per year: $8268 [with 90% between $6200-$11000].
http://paa2008.princeton.edu/download.aspx?submissionId=8035...
Hispanic TFR 2.5-2.8. Roughly, the average number of children per woman over lifespan.
http://www.census.gov/compendia/statab/2011/tables/11s0690.p...
Median Hispanic household income: $37912.
For your median Hispanic household, during school age years with 3 kids we're talking about $24,900 per year in taxpayer expenditures, which is about 65% of their household income. This is likely significantly more than is paid in taxes by the household and is one line item; we have not yet included medical bills or the array of other costs borne by society.
Business owners are currently fobbing off the costs of unskilled immigration (illegal and otherwise) on the rest of society; your cheap produce is not cheap.
Furthermore, its not clear we in America are so poor we must operate on an immediate-profit bases, especially when considering human capital. You for instance. Should we eject you, probably a student by the sound of it, because you are not currently profitable?
Now you argue that you're already an American, which is true but firmly on the "I've got mine" side of politics and not pretty.
If it is an investment then we do need to look at these bottom line metrics.
http://cis.org/immigrant-welfare-use-2011
However, data on estimated tax liability is present, and it suggests immigrants are liable for very little in tax. This should be unsurprising - taxes are primarily paid by the highest income brackets, and immigrants tend to lie within the lowest income brackets.
How do Germany and other high-wage countries manage harvesting?
They invest in automation instead of pushing for what is close to indentured servitude, as American agribusiness does.
Actually we prefer servitude over automation, too. Our harvesters come from Poland, Hungary and Romania. Much cheaper than expensive machines.