In other words: The preferred results were not found (females are oppressed) so we ignore wrong-think results (males seem to be) and continue to hunt evidence for preferred results elsewhere.
In other words: The preferred results were not found (females are oppressed) so we ignore wrong-think results (males seem to be) and continue to hunt evidence for preferred results elsewhere.
Note that I think it’s a fine thing to stick to one’s priors until they’ve been conclusively disproven, but recognition when the evidence obviously challenges one’s priors is my baseline for good faith. That said, I suspect this paper is written as it was because the authors thought their careers might be in danger for merely suggesting that the disparity might have a cause beyond discrimination.
I'm using this phrase the next time my daughters are playing and they start to yell at each other.
I’m confused, the study does suggest we look for anti-female bias elsewhere. Indeed, the authors seem to argue that it must exist elsewhere, and more powerfully so in order to explain the gender gap.
Why is anti-female bias the only possible explanation of the gap? Why is that the only acceptable hypothesis? It's a possibility, it might even be probable, but there seems to be an exclusionary focus both in your comments and in the abstract.
If your goal is to "find evidence for X" instead of "find out the truth" (wherever that leads you), you're a terrible scientist.
I think it is pretty clear which is happening in this case, no?
From a strictly scientific standpoint, you can’t really draw such “must be” conclusions. It could also very well be that the input into the existing funnel is low; I.e that there is a lower percentage of female founders because females make a lower percentage of the applicant pool.
And, to be clear, the disparity could also be due to stronger biases further into the investment process!
It’s just that we don’t know whether it’s the former or the latter (or some combination), and based on the research here it is inappropriate to draw that specific conclusion. That’s not a scientific approach.
Where does it mention that there is an overall anti-female bias?
The reasoning appears to be something like, "Because there is a disparity, there must be an anti-female bias somewhere and since there's only a pro-female bias here, the elsewhere anti-female bias must be so strong as to overcome the pro-female bias here to produce the disparity". There seems to be an implicit assumption that disparities are proof of bias when in fact bias is one of many potential causes of disparities.
They should design an experiment suitable to justifying that conclusion, if that's what they wanted to prove. at best, the author's should conclude on that particular thread, "more research is needed."
It's true that any discrimination in favour of one group would be discrimination against the opposite.
But as a middle-class white guy at a big tech company, whose boss is a middle class white guy whose boss is a middle class white guy whose boss is a middle class white guy whose boss is a middle class white guy whose boss is a middle class white guy whose boss, the CEO, is a rich white guy... I don't feel very oppressed.