Do Not Debase Science: Don't Call On It To Settle Your Medieval Disputes - Richard Feynman
collectedthoughts.com
collectedthoughts.com
Not by any means to pick on the Jewish faith, but aren't Rabbis notorious for detailed, obscure, nit-picking arguments that go on forever? Seems like I remember stories of medieval rabbis getting into the oddest debates.
Yes. You know philosophy has become specialized when there's a symmetrical relationship between any two topics. We have the history of philosophy, and the philosophy of history. Likewise, we have the philosophy of sociology and the sociology of philosophy. The science of philosophy, and the philosophy of science.
I'm hoping to go for the gold and specialize in the sociology of the history of the science of philosophy. I figure there will be one other guy in the world with the same specialty. We can argue by writing papers ad inifinitum.
But those medieval guys, sure, they wasted a lot of time. (humor making a point guys)
Judaism is a very logically oriented religion. It's not obvious but every single rules is very logically determined. Except for a specific list that is termed "rules from Sinai". (I don't remember the exact count of how many things are termed so.) Those are like the 'axioms' everything else follows logically from there.
It is said that by starting with those rules, the text of the torah, and nothing else, you can regenerate the entire set of laws.
What? Hu? Where in the world did I say that? Or even anything close? I said the "implications".
Just so it's clear: there is no prohibition for floating cities.
The issues discussed were pretty technical, but had to do with public vs. private land on the city.
At least it isn't a spam blog. You might be able to argue fair use.
The original purpose of Shabbat in Judaism and Christianity is to devote one day out of seven to meditation and prayer, as well as to simulate the sinless state, in which there was no need for work, that existed before the Fall. There's nothing special about Saturday (or Sunday) as opposed to any other day, aside from the desire to have all observers recognize it on the same day. Before the modern era, the most common distraction from the meditative life was work, and hence the activities that are prohibited are those that were considered part of the "work" sphere in biblical times.
Organized religion tends to calcify, leading to strict rules that allow no exceptions. Hence, the question asked is not, "Will using electricity distract from the meditative purpose of Shabbat?" but "Does electricity 'count' as a fire?" Of course, one can't single out Judaism here, because significant components of all the major religions devolve into the same debates.
Similarly, they do not indicate an "original purpose" for Shabbat; there is only a few repeated words surrounding the commandment to observe it.
To say there is nothing special about Saturday implies that you have already entirely missed the point; it is only because of this tradition (or possibly the Babylonians, who may have had it first) that we use a seven day week at all.
Actually, the tradition regarding what qualifies as work is significantly more specific than you seem to think; the 39 melochot are the categories of tasks involved in the construction and operation of the tabernacle--all work on which was specifically prohibited for Shabbat, so associated tasks are prohibited into modern times.
All systems of thought tend to calcify over time, as the same concepts and results continue to be repeatedly verified; one can't single out religion in this regard, just because the major religions are among the eldest organized systems of thought.
You aren't allowed to work and you are stuck with your spouse. And religions seem to be fond of encouraging reproduction.
Being with your spouse is encouraged, but not because of reproduction, but rather because it's enjoyable, and that is one of the things that Shabbat is about: rest, and enjoyment.
I was trying to say that because it's enjoyable, simply being with your spouse is encouraged, even if reproduction is not going to happen (not the right time, already pregnant, too old, etc).
b: The rule was never: forbid things that are work. Work is a poor translation of the hebrew concept. Things that are forbidden are things that create things, or modify them. Like burning something, or building. The idea is to emulate God - God stopped creating the world on the 7th day, so we too should not create things on the 7th day. What counts as creating for God and for us are different, but the idea is the same.
c: There is something special about the particular 7th day: it's the same day that was seventh after creation. The weeks have been counted continuously for a good many thousands of years.
So to ask '"Will using electricity distract from the meditative purpose of Shabbat?" instead of "Does electricity 'count' as a fire?"' completely misses the point of Shabbat.
You think you are catching the point, but instead you missed it.
And BTW the answer to the question is: yes it counts as fire because using electricity causes a fire in the power plant to be increased. But the electricity itself is not fire.
Orthodox Jews for nuclear power!!
1) Is a regenerative break in an elevator doing work, even if the power is not fed back into the grid? Accepted answer: No, as long as its not fed back, but wasted as heat instead in a large resistor. Solution : A special system was constructed to divert the regenerative power into a large nickel-chromium element and not fed back into the grid for just that day. This heat was vented outside so that it wouldn't accidentally do work by heating the building in winter.
2) Does energy created in the power plant (from burning coal) count if its stored in a battery and then removed during Shabbat? Answer: No, as long as the fire part happened some other day. Solution: Large batteries were installed with inverters to feed critical systems during this day and were only charged during the week.
Of course, as mentioned, non Jews were hired to press buttons, open doors, and perform other actions during this time as well. The moral of the story is that it cost a lot more, and takes a lot longer to build a building like this!
I believe in God, and I don't want to disparage any man's religion but I think personally that God is not overly impressed by storing the energy in a battery so we can use it guilt free on the holy day...
Second: you need to understand that the main thing going on here is that non jews (who do not need to keep shabbos) are pressing the buttons, etc.
And normally that would be enough - no need for batteries and resistors.
But it's in israel, and in israel non-observant jews run the power plants, so what happens is that by going in the elevator the jew is causing another jew (in the power plant) to violate the shabbos, and that's a huge problem. (I suppose it's actually the non-jew who is causing it. That's not a problem for the non-jew, but a jew should not use an elevator knowing it's going to cause someone to violate the shabbos.)
That's why they added all the batteries and stuff, and that's also why it's not simply a joke. The "loophole" if you will is the non-jew pressing the buttons, and that's fine. Non-jews are not required to keep shabbos, and you'd be all set. But the jew must not cause another jew to violate the shabbos, hence disconnecting from the grid.
You might ask: what about lights and stuff that are left on? And indeed there are those who run on batteries all shabbos. But the majority say that the jew is not doing any action by leaving the light on, and it's only actions that are a problem. For example: everyone agrees that it's ok to leave a fire running on shabbos, as long as you don't make it larger or smaller, same with the lights.
Does this mean that by inaction, its ok cause work to be done, even if by reasonable action, one could have prevented it?
Could the elevators simply move by themselves, stopping at every floor. Would it be permitted to ride them since they were simply "left on" and you wouldn't have to press any buttons, and they would have made the trip anyway?
(This is all according to the traditions recognized as authoritative by Orthodox Jews. The Kera'ites, a dissident sect going back at least to medieval times, interprets the Bible differently; they think you're not just allowed to ignite a fire on Shabbat, you're also not allowed to leave a fire burning over Shabbat. If you're a Kera'ite you should probably not live any place where there are cold winters.)
Yes, but _you_ didn't cause it. The restrictions are on actions, not on results. Almost all rules are on actions not results. For example you may not kill one person to save many, because you killed that one person. The final outcome is not totally up to you, but the single killing is.
>Does this mean that by inaction, its ok cause work to be done, even if by reasonable action, one could have prevented it?
Yes.
>Could the elevators simply move by themselves, stopping at every floor. Would it be permitted to ride them since they were simply "left on" and you wouldn't have to press any buttons, and they would have made the trip anyway?
Yes, except in israel where, because riding them causes more (or less) fuel to be burnt (because of your weight), and the power plants are run by jews it's a problem.
PS. Sorry for replying to this to very very late.