Yes, there have to be visual cues to know that it is a button. There has to be contrast. There should be a hover state that changes the contrast/color when hovering over it. The shape can indicate that it is button.
While I love the technical accomplishment of the OP and think it is a great thought experiment, I wouldn't want this arcade-button everywhere.
I believe skeuomorphic design, when overused makes a website harder to mentally process.
If this were the sole button consistently used on a web app, and the 3D button fit with the website's design, then maybe it would be good.
However, I would hate for a generation of HN users to see this post and think they should regress to designs reminiscent of 1998/2007.