I think I remember what it was now. Local configuration (DHCP?) contained two DNS servers. systemd-resolved switched to the global fallback when it tried one of the local servers and it failed, instead of falling back to the other local server first. It's a completely reasonable configuration to have two local servers for redundancy as well as load balancing, and systemd-resolved broke the redundancy aspect. It was not about a "wrong" global fallback, but about using it when a local alternative still works. It breaks local network name resolution.