There's nothing fundamentally nicer about living in a very thin walled low quality "mobile" home rather than a more solid nicer "prefabricated" home on the same plot.
There's nothing fundamentally nicer about living in a very thin walled low quality "mobile" home rather than a more solid nicer "prefabricated" home on the same plot.
https://www.trulia.com/research/new-or-existing-home/
> We found that that new homes (those built in 2013 or 2014) are typically priced 20% higher than older homes with similar attributes (e.g., square footage, bedrooms, bathrooms, etc.) and in the same zip code.
Another example is the higher tier hotel brands won’t sell you their branding to convert older buildings, you have to build new (unless you have a very desirable location, but that’s beside the point).
Also, the IRS lets you depreciate buildings, but not land:
https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-regs/depreciation_faqs_v2.pdf
I do not think the IRS would let people do that if they thought buildings maintained their value.
Lol. The "updated code and technical advances" are part of what keeps the value of existing structures from losing value.
Between ever increasing setback rules and asinine code changes that preclude features people actually want (like electrical outlets that are easy to use) and waste ever increasing space (look at the code for stairways and doorway sizes over the years).
For everyone getting suckered into a modern spec home there's someone else buying something because you can't build whatever that something is anymore. This is even more true with commercial operations where you can buy a facility but you couldn't get a new facility through the permitting process.
That is not evidenced by transaction data. There’s a few, mostly urban areas where older builds are valued due to not having to conform to modern codes, but certainly not representative of all existing structures versus new.
The easiest evidence I can offer is the IRS letting you deduct depreciation for buildings. Surely they would only do this if existing structures did lose value.
Older buildings may be deemed worth less on average partially because not all are well maintained and many may trivially hide expensive problems due in part to defects in workmanship and in part due to defective or absent maintenance.
People will pay a premium not to deal with anyone else's problems or even a chance of same.
In practice, people continually put money into permanent homes to update it, because their property as a whole is widely seen as an investment. It’s a package deal.
Mobile homes have none of this. They are not attached to land. The transactions in which they are transferred are not connected to land. They’re usually titled, and often sit on rented land.
Trulia is partially measuring the fact that the set of homes that are 2 years old inherently contain ~zero homes that have fallen into disrepair.
Two houses 20 years apart in manufacture date that are similar in overall quality, rather than superficial MLS data, will not have a significant price differential.
Mobile homes are very different in this regard. A 40 year old traditional home may still have a lot of value, partially because they are sold with the land.
It is not uncommon for mobile homes to depreciate like a car, or worse. Perfectly livable but older mobile homes can sell for 4 or even 3 digit prices.
Of course, mobile homes will depreciate much quicker than non mobile, but wear and tear and technological advances happen to old buildings nonetheless.
Obvious deficiencies, like old mechanicals, are what I’m referring to by a home being “maintained”.
Mobile homes, on the other hand, are often exempt from many building codes and are notorious for their use of proprietary or non-standard parts. They’re throwaway construction.
On the other hand, in many places I've lived, owning or renting a trailer was the closest folks can get to a house or the easiest/cheapest way to get a place with space.
None of this is a secret, either. Every poor person I knew that saw trailers as a better option than renting knew the downsides.
And honestly, it isn't that much upfront. Generally cheaper than a house with monthly payments lower than rent, and that is including lot rent, if you have it. Total rent is generally cheaper than a like sized house if you are just renting. No shared walls. You can often have pets.
When your option is to rent part of a house, especially from a not-so-wonderful landlord, this is a nice option. It literally doesn't matter if you don't get your money back or if it doesn't seem like a good investment.
Few folks are in it for the investment, but honestly, most folks aren't really buying a house for the investment, but rather that they get some freedom and security (the bank won't kick you out for willy-nilly reasons: A landlord can simply decide not to renew your lease, at least in places with poor renter's protections). Quality of life things are important.
He owns the trailer, but the park jacks up the rent. So he's caught behind not being able to afford the cost to move his trailer, and the steadily increasing rent which is slowly driving him further into poverty.
I've tried to help him out of it, but he won't accept any help.