Emails need to be clear and concise. HTML facilitates far too much hidden shit.
Emails need to be clear and concise. HTML facilitates far too much hidden shit.
Not that I personally disable all JS in my browser, but I'd say if your website can not be displayed without Javascript, then it is silly.
Javascript's terrible when it's used to generate pages from bloated frameworks that create 5000 DOM elements, add listeners to everything, load a dozen external scripts, and so on, but it's really valuable when used to actually improve the user experience.
Rather, they do so because it enables a majority of websites, and this includes big names like news websites, to create an absolutely horrible user experience - even if, or seemingly because, the content profits in no way from JS.
If you have ever tried to surf on an older laptop recently, you will get what I mean.
Only three engines exist that work well with JS; if we want our sites to not be dependent on behemoths like Google and Apple (Google is Mozilla's income source), we need to build sites that don't depend on their software (Blink, Webkit, and Gecko). That typically means not requiring JS.
People who block JS do so for good reason: when they open your site, they have no reason to believe that the JS being served isn't malware. If they disable and inspect it, they have no reason to believe that the scripts won't change the next time they open your page. It's safer to just leave it disabled.
I have Javascript off by default and only turn it on (using NoScript extension) whenever it's actually needed.
Most pages load just fine without and with those that don't it's a 50/50 between me enabling JS for it or deciding I didn't wanna view the content anyways and closing the tab.
As someone else mentioned it's not to deprive myself of functionality, but to deprive the vultures (trackers and other shady stuff) of it.
I normally browse with a browser that doesn't even support JS (Lynx, NetSurf, or Dillo). Glad to know that anyone who doesn't use a browser developed by a company running on billions of dollars a year is just being "silly".
If I am compelled to use a "modern" browser, I turn off JS, cookies, remote fonts, WebGL, and any third-party resources and enable them on a case-by-case basis if the website is important enough (it usually isn't). Most sites worth visiting work much better when I do this.
“Organizations should ensure that they have disabled HTML from being used in emails, as well as disabling links. Everything should be forced to plain text. This will reduce the likelihood of potentially dangerous scripts or links being sent in the body of the email, and also will reduce the likelihood of a user just clicking something without thinking about it. With plain text, the user would have to go through the process of either typing in the link or copying and pasting. This additional step will allow the user an extra opportunity for thought and analysis before clicking on the link.”
https://theconversation.com/the-only-safe-email-is-text-only...
That said theres another post on the front page about an Apple mail zero click exploit involving attachments so even plain text can’t dodge everything.
I can see the value in linking, embedding images, highlighting through bold and italic text, and underlining. Even code can be useful inside an email. Markdown or a similar language would serve most people very well, much better than HTML. Non-automated and fully automated emails can do with a strong simplification.
Of course, marketing companies will always prefer full HTML because it allows for making their spam more gaudy and for making their emails follow their brand, usually through terrible abuse of tables and CSS that in the end only make emails unreadable on mobile, with dark mode enabled, or massively confuse screen readers.
My perfect world email markdown will probably be different from yours. For productivity, anything more than slightly stylised text is just unnecessary, but in practice, most email isn't used for productivity anymore. Instant messaging has replaced email as a means of conversation in all workspaces I know.
The millions of people you refer to probably (without realizing) send multipart messages with a plaintext version available. Emails without this are typically spam.
Marketing emails can be annoying but that’s what the unsubscribe button is for ;)
Allowing fewer features is a feature in itself: when we try to allow everything without thinking about the consequences, we end up with something like the modern Web or Electron apps.