I can just imagine the panic of having to increase the field size by a single digit, it'd be a billion dollar, decade long problem that never gets fixed.
Maybe the current SSN will just be a prefix, with additional suffix digits, like zip codes.
I'm sure they'll be reused at some point. Maybe there will be a market for used celebrity SSNs.
SSNs are used as unique identifiers. If you start re-using them, they're no longer unique.
Nothing about SSNs is ideal. The uniqueness and permanence assumption is part of why identity theft is so calamitous. So sharing an SSN with someone who's been dead 20 years seems preferable to sharing one with someone who is reusing yours.