Right? They're night and day different in France. What exactly causes this? General store American ones often may as well be thin red latex bags of water.
If you grow your own tomatoes, the results can be amazing.
30 years ago, my grandmother grew the most amazing tomatoes in her vegetable garden on the farm. When she died my uncles sold off the farm and a developer split it into 5 or 6 plots that are now mostly horse pastures with huge McMansions on them. So it goes.
I'm American. Possibly there are a lot of people like me here, so the stores are actually providing what the people want.