I was self-studying Russian for quite some time, with decent progress. But when I came to Seoul and ran into some native Russian speakers, I discovered that I could barely put my sentences together in real-time. I made some changes to my approach and a year later was able to conversate, read articles, and watch movies without any aid.
The "one weird trick" to it was to spend literally hundreds of hours one on one with tutors online. It's not an option for everybody, of course, but if you can do it - do it. Studying with flash cards and apps helps too, but your brain more importantly needs to practice understanding strings of words and putting them together yourself in real-time.