When you register for notifications it sends out a verification email. That would be a good time to let you disable public lookup of your email address.
I also wish HIBP could securely disclose the snippet of information from a leak that's relevant to you. Knowing the password or hash characteristics, phone number, etc. could aid in mitigation, and seeing the raw impact might help motivate ordinary users to improve their security hygiene.
Suggested that idea to Troy in the past, and got the impression he's not amenable, largely due to the risks of hosting PII. Can't really blame him.
For anyone else who's hesitant to use the link, these are the three choices presented when you opt out: https://i.imgur.com/4lB2bSq.png
If you pick the first one, you can still use the notification service (https://haveibeenpwned.com/NotifyMe) to email yourself a private link to check what breaches include the address (past and current).
The ones marked sensitive have more a pattern of "we don't want to be caught in a court caste about hosting the info" than a pattern of trying to improve privacy in the ways this thread is suggesting.
If you have the data itself, then lookup is as simple as 'grep' or 'ctrl-f'
So anyone who has the means to compromise someone they're looking up by having the data doesn't need the HaveIBeenPwned tool in the first place.
Moot point, IMHO.
...and that your friends deserve a better friend than someone who would look up their email addresses to embarrass them.
My public email address is not the one I use for logins anywhere.
Did I give a fake DOB. Is it a previous address? Do they actually even have an address or is it just NULL for me? HIBP won't tell me.
99.99% of people would not go through this effort and lack the skill/knowledge, even if they were motivated against someone.
But I appreciate your point.
There's still a need gap to detect leaked file data online, Say after a ransomware attack our files end-up in pastebin[1]; currently there seems to be no way to know unless manually monitoring sites where leaked data is posted or for the attacker to themselves let you know.
[1] Added in my profile.