I've done a little end-user support, and this is a pretty optimistic take on what you'd get. It would probably be more like "It didn't work." in both cases. Maybe you'd get "there was an error message"
Q: What do you see on your screen? A: Nothing
Q: Try again and tell me what happens. A: It didn't work and I still don't see anything.
Many people have an automatic reactions to any kind of error or message. They get dismissed automatically. It seems that some people don't even realize they're doing it.
'not connected. more info: blah #32893289327". Microsoft did something similar with an error code that you could google. that was super useful for debugging. the error message was in laymen terms though.
Error IDs on everything, please.