How does one know a site like this is not just an other data harvesting site?
Just enter your email and the site will tell you whether your email has been harvested by https://haveibeenfacebooked.com/
Other than Troy Hunt being well known and building a reputation on being a white hat security guy.
In the world of data the only thing you can trust in absolute terms is encryption. Anything else involving people involves shades of grey.
I could see the "big-data" value of that information if they managed to get a significant proportion of the population to check this website, but even that would be barely worth the effort.