Team Compensation by Mary Poppendieck [pdf]
poppendieck.com
poppendieck.com
You could leave out the word "IT" and still have a good point.
The other 90% spend their time attending meetings, writing memos, and otherwise looking busy but not actually adding value.
It's just that there are so few good managers; at all the large companies where I worked, it was an open secret who was contributing and who was just taking up space.
The majority was in the latter category.
Hacking might be all or nothing because the marginal cost of software is zero, but marginal costs in most other industries are a lot higher. Just compare software to working toilet. Selling another copy of software is essentially free. Selling another working toilet is not really free. In the libertarian world you describe, plumbers would have no trouble making a living off the precise market value of their labor. This is especially true for credence goods of all kinds; wages are very similar for different plumbers and mechanics, because nobody pays high prices for high quality (since it's impossible to recognize), and nobody buys the low-priced option because it's perceived (in the absence of other information) of being of lower quality.
Your theory is interesting, but not hard and fast.
Well a good surgeon would always take a safe & sure case, where he would almost succeed.
A "bad" surgeon would take the impossible (to save life, limb, etc.) cases, and he would fail way more...
Now really - who's good and who's bad?
If your child or you has something really terrible that's almost impossible (but still there is chance) to cure, whom of the "good" surgeons is going to help you?
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Nature_of_the_Firm
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ronald_Coase
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transaction_cost
Not to mention the principal/agent problem where people working independently have different incentives than people who are part of the firm.
I had to explain this to my boss the last time I had a full time job. He came up with the brilliant idea of using only contractors. The sad thing is that he majored in economics.
But I'm a hired gun, so I have a slanted view.
Let's try another analogy. I love start-ups, in which the marketplace rewards those products it finds most meritorious. You make things people find merit in, you get more money.
Looks to me that is two strikes against the views represented in the article. I guess you could make the case that there are full-timers who are interested in lots more besides money. In this case, the marketplace still rewards the meritorious work, it's just that management gets to keep the extra money and screws over the little guy.
There has to be some kind of middle ground. If my team invents the next google while working at company XYZ, I don't want a T-shirt and an opportunity to become senior muck-slucker. I want a cut of the action.
Is that so unreasonable?
I'm not sure what the solution would be in this case, but Google used to give out Founders awards, were by if you created a cool new technology or product they would try to compensate you as if you were a startup they had to buy.
They ended up scrapping this as it, in their estimation, caused more harm that good with in the company.
The article described a situation like this (well, not quite Google maybe), but the company wanted to single out 1-2 team members for reward, while ignoring the rest. I'm all for being paid better for performance, but when working as a team, there's something to be said for rewarding the successful team, not just an individual or two.
Definitely a different story if you're a hired gun, and I've been on both sides of the table there.
For good developers, the only motivation you need is already intrinsic to them, that is the desire to do awesome work and be recognized for this by their peers. Just facilitate this, sit back and enjoy the show.
Lame rewards confuse the picture and (a) piss off the guys who are bound to feel slighted, and (b) dilute genuine motivation with a perceived need to look good to managers.
Everbody puts his vote for who he thought was the best one in the team (he can even name himself).
Or something like this.
Nothing like a typo in 48-point font.