I'd personally be happy if we did that even now, but the longer we put it off, the larger the cost to be paid.
Your last point describes a corrupt government which can happen either way, and is not particularly relevant to environmental policy.
I'd personally be happy if we did that even now, but the longer we put it off, the larger the cost to be paid.
Your last point describes a corrupt government which can happen either way, and is not particularly relevant to environmental policy.
Some replacements are physically constrained (like lithium for batteries). There has been a lot of money already spent to find replacements like super capacitors, and for much longer than 10 years.
Do you think that invalidates my point?
[Edited in response to your edit: fuel and battery technology has improved significantly over the last decade, with little or no political pressure, and shows signs that it will continue to improve. I expect that it would have improved more quickly with political pressure, yes.]
This is a nonsense ad absurdum argument. It's self-evidently true that more devs will, in general, deliver projects more quickly - especially considering that we are talking about a system, not a single project.
Otherwise, we could have One True Dev delivering all of the world's software. Do you think that is reasonable?
Political pressure won't necessarily make a difference, as you say, but sustained and genuine political pressure will almost certainly make a difference.
You might want to look up Brooks's Law.
Look up Brooks's Law yourself. It begins with "under certain conditions", none of which apply here.
And do you have any points for why the exceptions to those circumstances would apply here? Or are you just stating that as fact, like the rest of your argument? It seems like you are relying on the fallacy fallacy (yes that's a real thing) - don't bother proving your own opinion, just say that mine is wrong because you think I have a fallacy.
The price reductions in all rare-earth based technologies come from governments and consumers alike turning a blind eye to the means with which they are extracted. Any political pressure to make those processes more environmentally friendly or less, umm, slavey, will make them more expensive.