Serbia is 7M people for gosh stakes it's the size of Greater Toronto or Chicago, there doesn't need to be a 'giant bureaucracy'.
Serbia is 7M people for gosh stakes it's the size of Greater Toronto or Chicago, there doesn't need to be a 'giant bureaucracy'.
Important governmental services tend to be understaffed, either because the work is arduous, unpleasant or does not pay enough to attract competent individuals.
What tends to grow are services that are politically expedient.
Of course government services can have too many or too few workers, that's a matter of efficiency.
All rich nations have mostly socialized infrastructure: water, electricity, roads and partially socialized retirement and healthcare.
That's partly why they are rich.
You can't save people from themselves.
There's an awful lot of libertarian, social darwinist claptrap in threads on this post. It gets away from the fact that what has happened is a relatively newly capitalist country has made a very substantial error to its citizens' cost, and there exists a possibility of injustice alongside the possibility that the rule of law may appear to be being ignored, depending on when the law changed.
It isn't an opportunity to be performatively callous.
All rich countries have some kind of basic retirement benefits and some measure public medical care (the US spends more per capita on socialized medicine than does Canada) - this is partly why they are rich.
It's not even controversial anymore, it hasn't been for 70 years.
Croatia’s had pretty decent universal healthcare for many years.
Croats just save differently to others due to corruption and adversity in their country: an average Croat's wealth is in real estate. As there is no real estate tax on primary abode, real estate ownership is high, while the mortgage debt is almost nonexistent. Where do you think 7.5 billion euros which pour in every Summer from tourism go? That money mostly ends up in the newly built villas on the coast.
This doesn't make a lot of sense, if there is low interest rates and no estate or real estate tax, then people should naturally have considerable leverage.
This is just one example. In the '90's, bank of Ljubljana simply froze, then siphoned off all of their Croatian customers' assets in Croatia to their central office in Slovenia. Nobody ever saw any of their money up to this present day, and are unlikely to ever see it. Nobody went to jail, and it is unlikely anyone ever will. There are a sea of such examples in that country. This is why in Croatia, one borrows cash from family, relatives and friends at no interest, rather than get screwed over by the state and all kinds of private institutions, none of which can be trusted. Croats have zero confidence in their government or anyone else for that matter, sometimes they do not, or cannot even trust their own family or would-be friends.
It's pointless to talk about the efficiency of public systems, for even the effectiveness of wealth taxes etc. if corruption is endemic, particularly in the financial sector.
If the banking sector is corrupt - there can be no real economy.
And FYI this notion of 'no mortgage debt' as something healthy is completely wrong. 'Credit' is the lifeblood of an economy, if you want to get people into good housing, it's essential. Mortgages enable people to spread payments out over time and are a fundamental artifact of affordability. Mo mortgages = bad housing and fewer jobs in the construction sector.
There can be risk of housing bubbles etc. but that can be effectively managed. Or should be, a lot of countries struggle with that.
I also did not talk nor did I write about any efficiency of any public system, so that does not concern me or what I wrote about either.
"If the banking sector is corrupt - there can be no real economy."
There is no economy in Croatia; it has very little industry of any significance, with tourism being the only significant influx of funds into the country.
"Mortgages enable people to spread payments out over time and are a fundamental artifact of affordability."
SIGH Sir, how do I explain this? You are so deep into classical economy thinking, whereas the reality in Croatia is one of tribal mentality. People take on debts from friends and family, and nobody worries about making payments the way you understand them, because the money owed is paid back in cash, with physical bills, in person and in one lump sum. Cars, condominiums, houses... it has always been this way in Croatia, for hundreds of years, and will be that way for a very, very long time, possibly the next hundred years, if not longer. It's Croatia: that is the only way that people there were able to come up with which functions reliably. Ergo, nobody gives a flying fuck about a mortgage over there, that's just something one reads about on the InterNet. No Croat will trust themselves to apply for one after all that corruption, and even if one did, nowadays the banks are reluctant to lend money to consumers. So the chances of both parties coming together to consume a financial transaction are zero. It has effectively become a cash only economy, and even though kuna has been a stable currency for almost three decades now, every Croat will convert their excess cash (which they hide at home) into euros, cash again, the first chance they get.
When a Croat goes to buy a car, he or she will literally walk around with a small sport bag full of physical currency. There was a period of people going deep into debt with consumer credit to buy cars, of course that has failed spectacularly with most being unable to service their debt, so things are back to the usual - cash.
When a Croat goes to buy a house, he or she will literally walk around with a briefcase full of stacked bills.
Why are you commenting on a thread about X and Y, and then saying 'X and Y are none of my concern and have nothing to do with me?'
You original response was in a thread concerning public welfare systems.
You commented extensively about financial systems in response to issues concerning mortgage debt and credit.
"You are so deep into classical economy thinking,"
This has nothing to do with 'classical economics' it has to do with a working financial system.
What you just did was more effectively explain why Croatia is poor. If banks are corrupt and/or don't offer credit, and if consumers have no interest in it, then of course, a credit system won't exist and it will keep Croatia poor.
If, as you say, Croatia won't have anything but a 'cash economy for hundreds of years' then Croatia will be poor for hundreds of years.
It's like not having electricity or water.
It's not a negative thing, it's a positive thing.
Advanced economies run on credit, not cash and it's a matter of allocating services and resources more efficiently based on need, and of course, being able to plan ahead for outcomes.
Nations that don't have a functioning financial and credit system will not be wealthy, it's just that simple.
Here is a YouTube by Ray Dalio where he explains what credit is, and how it functions in the economy. [1]
By the way, you incorrectly assume that I am financially illiterate. I have done more than 100,000 trades with complex financial instruments. Debt is extremely toxic and dangerous.
All businesses and nations carry debt, it's a financial instrument like any other, and it's a very useful thing.
Like all things, it can be misused.
This isn't remotely controversial.
Saying 'debt is toxic and dangerous' is like saying 'roads are toxic because they have cars, which can lead to crashes', it's completely bizarre.
These financial systems are part what enables rich countries to be rich. Nations that don't have the ability to structure are poor, it's that simple.
1. how the financial system works;
2. how broken and corrupt it is.
For several decades I worked in the financial industry, in the very core of it; I was there smack dab in the middle of it, working at a certain institution when that institution caused the 2008 crash (that's why I exited stage left, because I am not a crook and disagreed with it). The current debt-based economy is a time-ticking bomb. When it comes to the great reset, it will be the worst recession which the world has ever known.
The zero trust in state and banks syndrome, I have it too. I'm from a different Eastern European country though. Since I don't trust the pensions, I save up individually.