What an interesting comment, thanks for taking the time to write it.
> That's irrelevant, as the program can't be derived from the rules. To understand the behavior of the program (the universe) you need to know both the rules (physical laws) and the source code of the program (physical constants/quantities).
This does not remove the fact that the universe could be built from a very few simple laws. (my first and only point in my previous comment)
As with softwares, even if we do not know the 'source code' we can infer it. How? By designing experiments. There are then three possibilities:
1. Every experiment confirm our theory, in this case we believe with a certain degree of certitude that the model is a good approximation of the reality,
2. An experiment give results that do not correspond to our model, then we need to change or improve our model,
3. Two experiments on the same phenomenon give contradicting results. We finally found a bug, the behavior is undefined, maybe our universe collapse, maybe we are in a giant simulation and we found a limits of higher floating point numbers.
> This is similar to QM and the Standard Model. QM has a very elegant set of simple rules of motion that describe how particles interact. But there are infinitely many possibile universes that behave according to Schrodinger's equation. To see how our universe behaves, you also need the Standard Model, with its dozens of particles and relationships between them and constants and dimensions.
I do not see exactly why it is relevant but I would add that the standard model in not enough, lots of things exists in physics where we cannot define an experiment to decide what is the (our) reality. But we do not really care because the realities are somewhat equivalent.
> In contrast, String Theory only has one 'particle', the string,...
I will not address this comment. I think your point is that physics can be defined experimentally or mathematically and the mathematical version has more chances to be wrong because the minimum set or rules are more arbitrary?
> There's a good chance Wolfram's models will turn up the same way - a new mathematical formalism that, if you plug in all of the constants of the Standard Model, predicts the Standard Model precisely.
Sure there are chances that string theory and Wolfram's theory are a game of the mind and they are fundamentally flawed. But it is also true that if you chose well your first principles and they are easy enough, if both theories can be used to infer a wide variety of phenomenas, there is a good chance that there is an isomorphism between the first principles and they are equivalent in essence, so why bother, go for the system you believe in, hope to make great discoveries and one day, maybe, your theory will be merged with a better theory, but it is rarely lost. Theories are adapted and improved ;)