> If a study doesn’t replicate then it’s almost certainly nonsense.
For some fields, especially natural sciences, this statement makes sense. However, for sciences of the artificial (to use Herb Simon's term) I would respectfully disagree.
For example, sometimes the underlying context has changed. I remember a luminary in my field (HCI) once argued that we should consider re-doing many studies every decade, because each cohort uses a different set of tools and has a different set of experiences, and because the underlying demographics of those cohorts change.