I would have guessed thousands of times more dangerous.
I would have guessed thousands of times more dangerous.
Getting onto and off a paternoster is pretty exciting, so you won't be bored enough to look at the smartphone :-)
But as hinted at in the safety section, with modern sensors and some brains behind them paternoster can be made safe. You can even make them wheelchair accessible by gradually stopping a cabin and informing all other passengers about that.
And when a department in a large and busy office building is spread across a few floors then a paternoster is the most efficient way of moving between floors.
I used this argument when my workplace was encouraging people to "take the stairs" for supposed health reasons. It was rejected because science and statistics are only accepted when they support one's desired conclusions.
This is the case for cycling vs driving to work in at least some cities.
- most elevator accidents occur during maintenance, which I assume is similar for paternosters. So the fact that elevators are seemingly safer for passengers might not statistically factor in much to the overall safety record: e.g. paternosters could be 1000x as dangerous for passengers but only 5x as dangerous for technicians
- relatedly, I would suspect most paternosters are better maintained than most elevators and less likely to have a dangerous mechanical failure
- and as the commenters stated, passengers are likely to be more alert when using a paternoster (no accidents like stepping in to an empty shaft)
Regardless I suspect you are correct that a well-maintained paternoster is at least hundreds of times more dangerous for passengers than a well-maintained elevator. As far as I can tell the stats given on Wikipedia don’t refute that (but I wish I knew more about their source).
This doesn’t make sense to me. Outside of sensors that can automatically shut the motor off, the motor is definitely strong enough to do major damage in an unlikely crushing incident - it could easily sever or otherwise destroy a limb without even slowing down the carriage. The motor in any elevator has to be extremely strong: it’s not like paternosters slow down due to strain when people enter them.
To put it a bit gruesomely, the motor doesn’t notice the difference between lifting a 100kg passenger or applying the same amount of shear force to a trapped arm.
There were parliamentary moves to ban paternosters in Germany some time ago. However, the Bundesrat prevented this at the time. Later, operation was re-regulated with stricter safety requirements. This then mainly concerned the installation of all kinds of signs about the correct way to get on and off and to remain calm during the turnaround if you missed the last exit.
Personally, I would guess that most accidents are falls from getting on too late going down or too early going up.
There are still moving things with small gaps though, without non-moving times, so some number of injuries seems unavoidable. Given enough time, you can always discover an inattentive person.
I've seen a few paternosters in action and just checked a few random YouTube videos and I'm fairly sure that that pretty much all of them have plates between carriages. Your parent's concern appears unfounded.
And as another user already said, they look scary enough to make you pay attention.