I think this should be addressed with stronger privacy laws, but Google is capable of moving much faster than the EU government.
The pain they’re facing is that people don’t want to be tracked, and tracking/cohorts are the only edge that Google has. Without that they’re must another advertising wholesaler.
They have some trackingless ad options but they don't support any kind of HTML5 as far as I've heard.
Also, adtech just needs to take a step down to less tracking and targeting. They just don't get it. This would be an ideal time for smaller adtech companies to introduce ethical advertising with no tracking at all.
I'm not sure what about the algorithm can benefit them, they're just segmenting the population into cohorts, and again everyone has access to the exact same cohorts as Google does.
> gatekeeper to the tech
Won't the algorithm live in chromium and be open source?
> no tracking at all
People keep throwing that around but I honestly don't see how this works. All this does is benefit large companies like Coca Cola that blanket advertise to everyone, and screw over every small business who have niche specific demographic.
I have a friend who has a bicycle gear local shop, and he advertises specifically to local people who are into biking. There is no way in hell that non-targeted advertising could work for him. The majority of small products are made for a very niche demographic, so you're saying all of those should stop advertising entirely, except maybe on search results which have a query.
Of course, but Google decides what goes into Chrome. Chromium itself is a fringe phenomenon.
> I have a friend who has a bicycle gear local shop, and he advertises specifically to local people who are into biking. There is no way in hell that non-targeted advertising could work for him. The majority of small products are made for a very niche demographic, so you're saying all of those should stop advertising entirely, except maybe on search results which have a query.
He could advertise at a local news website, or a biking forum in the section for your town. Or sponsor a local initiative. Just like he probably did before ad tracking was pervasive. That way the money will also go straight to local people who can use it rather than dropping a large precentage in Google's (and other adtech) bucket.
It's not like this is actually a choice. Tracked advertising is going away one way or another. 47% of people are already using adblockers. https://www.digitalinformationworld.com/2019/04/global-ad-bl... (and that info is from 2019). Also, here in Europe it's got to be an opt-in mechanism now by law and there aren't many people who opt in.
If the industry doesn't quickly adapt there will be nobody left to view their ads :) And tracking is only one reason people block ads. A lot of people will be getting used to clean uncluttered websites right now and will find it hard to go back even when the original reason they installed the blocker has been removed.