Hacker News Reader

Comment by the_lonely_road | Hacker News Reader

You are 10 years too late for that concern. I often wonder if there are any real people commenting, submitting, or upvoting left on Reddit.

View on HN

I wouldn't go that far. There are tons of real people on it. A big problem problem though is the user base is so large and concentrated that it disguises the massive amounts of bots and "hidden" advertisement posts that get mixed in. And that low quality content drags the entire community down as "legitimate" posts are forced to compete for views/karma which was not their end-goal in the first place.

Reddit works when it isn't a competition, but advertising has made it a competition with a profit motive.

When using reddit, you need to stay away from the default subs. They are a timesink and repetitive, and because of the volume of users, the comments all start looking the same. People who were introduced through the mobile app usually make a lot of use of them.

You need to stick to the topic oriented subreddits. r/homelab for example.

I totally agree that the niche subreddits often have the best discourse.

I spend a lot of time on reddit and do not identify with your comment at all.

There’s real people for sure, but most of them are children and teenagers who are easily susceptible to corporate propaganda. I often wonder when a competitor will arise so that I can leave Reddit, and it’s rolling release of bad UX, for something better. At this point I would pay a monthly fee for a decent Reddit.

Plenty of competitors have risen over the years. They've have just all been abject failures. Most have tried to fix at least one aspect of the site and failed to do so. I don't even think a straight up copy would work at this point. Its got the user base and while never directly profitable, its value has always been in how easy it is to shill to the userbase. I think that's primarily why Advance keeps it.

Those children and teenagers are often more knowledgeable on the topic I'm searching for (especially with regards to gaming equipment), so I'm happy to take their opinion like anyone else's.

That said, a paid reddit would be a ghost town. It's against the spirit of the site.

This is emphatically not the case in my experience.

10 years later

Users: Now if I want good results, I append site:news.ycombinator.com before every query.

Advertisers: Hmmm...

I already tend to search hackernews first (with its dedicated search engine) for infocom-related queries !

Ditto for wikipedia and wikitionary, which are hopefully immune to advertising..

Reply on news.ycombinator.com