A Wrinkle in Nature Could Lead to Alien Life
nautil.us
nautil.us
This was eyebrow-raising for me, as I thought the consensus was advanced civilization was only "recently" possible due to the lack of heavy elements in the first generations of stars. The article fleshes out this claim a bit at the end...
> During the period when biochemistry could have first got underway—some 100 million years after the Big Bang—the heaviest elements were woefully scarce as the first generations of stars forged new atomic nuclei.
> Bereft of those atoms, terrestrial-sized planets might have wound up as “carbon worlds,”4 chemically rich in some ways, but with a severe shortage of some of the heavier elements that today’s life fully relies on. Life could have gotten going, but with different restrictions and imperatives.
...but still seems to be making a giant unsupported leap from "life may have been possible without heavy elements" to "advanced civilization may have been possible without heavy elements"
Iron, cobalt and nickel are the minimum set of elements required as catalysts and, as far as we know at this time, life cannot appear without them.
Actually life can appear using Fe, Co & Ni, when both dihydrogen and carbon monoxide are available in the environment. When only carbon dioxide is available instead of carbon monoxide, molybdenum or tungsten becomes also necessary.
So at least the elements around the iron peak are needed, which are produced in supernovas. Realistically, for the evolution of more complex life forms, also a few of the heavier elements that are produced in intense neutron fluxes are also required.
So no, according to current knowledge life was impossible 12 billion years ago and I cannot see any workaround, because the catalysts are at least as essential for life as the light elements that compose the bulk of the living matter.
(And yes I get the arguments that "things could happen that are outside of our capacity to imagine" but while true at some levels it can only take you so far with fundamental finite properties like the number of elements in the periodic table and the compounds you can make with them)
At what point in time we can expect the first supernovas to seed planets with heavy elements?
Of course, I think it was rather a while longer before it cooled down enough for things other than raging thermonuclear fireballs to find hospitable.
Most living beings use molybdenum, but tungsten can replace molybdenum and it is used for this purpose by some living beings (mostly by Archaea).
It is pretty certain that the common ancestor of all existing living beings already had molybdenum enzymes, while tungsten began to be used later, as an adaptation to higher temperatures.
Nevertheless, there was a hypothesis that maybe before the oxygenation of the oceans tungsten was used in preference to molybdenum, because oxygenated molybdenum compounds are more soluble than oxygenated tungsten compounds while in reduced environments their solubility properties are reversed.
However this hypothesis is most likely wrong, because it is contradicted by the distribution and phylogeny of the molybdenum enzymes and tungsten enzymes, which are consistent with the universal use of molybdenum already much earlier than the evolution of the ability for water photolysis and with the gain of the ability to use tungsten as an alternative only in certain archaea and bacteria.
The earliest life forms were probably dependent on having ammonia and carbon monoxide in their environment, as sources of carbon and nitrogen, in which case molybdenum is not strictly needed.
The use of molybdenum enzymes enabled the use of the more abundant carbon dioxide and dinitrogen as sources of carbon and nitrogen. This achievement must have happened some time before LUCA (last universal common ancestor), which already had these enzymes.
We know of one planet, in one solar system, in one galaxy that supports life. And it is incredibly hard to collect data from other planets in our own solar system much less data from other solar systems and other galaxies may be impossible to get any meaningful information with regards to the existence of life.
But it's also the only data we have to go off of.
So the best we can say is that this couldn't have happened in those conditions.
I would argue that a better definition of life should be based on (a) entropy and (b) propagation. Living systems (a) actively counteract entropy-increasing forces within their system as long as they are alive, and (b) are able to propagate indefinitely given the necessary energy inputs.
I've heard other definitions of life including dependence on water and I think those aspects should not be part of such a definition.
It is quite likely that there could be some alien life forms that would use much more varied silicon compounds than those used on Earth, but it is quite unlikely that there are environmental circumstances where silicon could replace carbon as the main structural element.
Silicon without carbon can provide only a much less variety of molecules and all the naturally occurring compounds are too stable, i.e. you cannot extract energy from them by rearranging the atoms, like you can in carbon compounds.
The most important condition for the appearance of life is an energy source. There are various abiotic processes that produce dihydrogen, carbon monoxide and carbon dioxide, and these gases can enter exothermic chemical reactions (e.g. dihydrogen + carbon monoxide => acetic acid), which can sustain life.
There are no such energy sources from silicon compounds. When oxygen is in excess, silicon forms silicates, otherwise it forms carbides and nitrides. All these are inert.
The only environment where silicon could play a role in the appearance of life would be a place with a very large abundance of hydrogen, i.e. a large planet like Jupiter, where it might happen that all the elements are present as compounds of hydrogen, so the silicon would be present as silanes, and there are differences in stability between various silanes that might be exploitable as an energy source if there exists any abiotic process that generates less stable silanes instead of the more stable silanes.
This possibility remains open just because I have not seen yet any model of such an environment to determine what compounds may appear and what chemical reactions are possible, so it cannot be completely excluded that silicon could play a role there, unlike on medium-size planets or smaller bodies, where the hydrogen is less abundant and silicon does not combine with it, but with the more electronegative elements.
I am not aware of any attempt to analyze what chemical reactions are possible in an environment with too much hydrogen, but I suspect that both the too oxidized environments with too much oxygen and the too reduced environments with too much hydrogen make impossible the occurrence of chemical reactions that could be used as a source of energy for life forms, so I think that life on Jupiter-like planets is unlikely.
To be able to mine for materials and manufacture new copies of itself is a more macroscopic way of creating those complex molecules than the smaller-scale processes used in Earth life, but I don't think that should be the differentiating qualifier for what constitutes life. It's rather just a different reproduction process than mitosis and meiosis but is a valid reproduction process.
To some extent I think we will invent silicon-based life or some other life to carry on our legacy after the solar system dies. Carbon-based Earth life is far too sensitive to environmental conditions, and what I envision of silicon-based life is something that can handle a much wider variety of temperatures, pressures, radiation, and gases, which would be much more suitable for a spacefaring continuation of humanity.
However we do not know any mechanism that would allow the spontaneous apparition of such living beings by natural processes, like those that exist for H, C, N, O and S as the main bioelements.
After some life forms appear spontaneously using a set of chemical elements very similar to that used on Earth, it might be possible at some point to transition to the use of other chemical elements, because the original constraints to start from substances that can be generated in abiotic conditions no longer apply.
So I agree that silicon-based life can exist, but there is no known process that could make silicon-based life forms appear spontaneously from non-living matter, unlike the case for carbon-based life.
Actually carbon-based life is a misnomer, because there are several other chemical elements that are strictly required for various reasons, so there is a minimum set of about 8 to 12 chemical elements that are needed for life, not only carbon.
While H, C, N, O and S are needed to build the minimal set of organic molecules and several transition metals are needed as catalysts, there are also a few other irreplaceable elements, e.g. potassium is needed to neutralize the excess negative charge of the organic acids over the positive charge of ammonium derivatives. (Other elements cannot replace potassium because they would form insoluble compounds).
Side point: One could also say that if we create silicon-based life forms to carry on our legacy, those life forms did in fact spontaneously appear, and "bacteria" and "dinosaurs" and "humans" were all part of that long but spontaneous process.
Such a process could happen elsewhere in the universe as well, but yes, that then requires C, N, O, S, H, etc. to exist for at least a few billion years.
I disagree with this. After each extinction event, even after the one who vanished 80% of existing species, geological studies showed that evolution only need ~10 million years to have the same diversity as before (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Permian%E2%80%93Triassic_extin...).
You could cull from all the branches of the tree of life evenly and keep wild genetic diversity vs killing off everything except for certain plants and bacteria.
The genetic diversity of a new continent would be highly dependent on the founder. If the founder has near perfect genetic replication and long lifespans measured by the century, the genetic diversity will be less than if you drop something that divides every half hour into a virgin pond.
You're also using extinction events on earth as a anchor point for the discussion where the entire point of the article is that our starting conditions as a civilization are not directly transferrable to considering other alien life.
My point is that mutations happens a lot (see current situation where the pandemic might actually become endemic exactly because the virus mutates so much) and diversity will always happen. And in the grand scheme of time measured by millions of years the diversity will 100% happen to fill all the free niches, regardless of the founder.
But even granting those premises, any early-universe super-civilization would eventually be cut off from its own distant reaches by expansion. This would be true of any civilization that expanded to its observable limits.
> This would be true of any civilization that expanded to its observable limits.
If stable traversable wormholes are at all possible, I'd expect one such civilization to be able to use networks of those to remain connected. Even if matter couldn't traverse them, information could.
But, then, if they resemble us in this sense, isolation will probably make them diverge.
> Our fairytale concepts of “galactic empires” could be woefully too conservative.
> theoretical possibilities for the fundamental parameters of nature to vary
> Room exists for future surprise.
> Even without these exotic possibilities, we know for sure that the environmental properties of the universe have changed since those same early times.
Right. The consequence is present without the premises. Any discovered alien life would likely be vastly different or at least vastly technologically progressed.