Monero, on the other hand...
- Ban anonymous cryptocurrencies.
- In pseudonymous cryptos, mark any address that has been the destination of a ransomware payment or demand as tainted. Any net positive transaction from a tainted source wallet marks the destination wallet as tainted. (I.e. you are obligated to return tainted monies to tainted wallets if they send money to you.)
- Exchanges are forbidden to deal with tainted wallets, or with any exchange that deals with tainted wallets.
While you're at it, I guess you could mark any wallet funded at an exchange that doesn't KYC as tainted as well, to limit the use of crypto for money laundering.
I'm guessing we're going to figure a lot of this stuff out in the next 10-20 years, if the crypto craze doesn't die off naturally during that timeframe.
The real fault lies with institutions rushing to half-assedly digitize so now they're wide open to script kiddies, and with enterprise IT providers doing a piss-poor job at doing correct software engineering. And now you're suggesting more savagery like it's some sort of solution to anything at all?
The war on drugs is bad because it doesn't work, and because drugs cause less harm than fighting them does. It's not an apt comparison to the situation we're talking about.
Which of the following causes more harm in total: (a) a ransomware gang attacking the computers of a hospital, thus endangering the lives of its patients; or (b) law-abiding citizens adhering to a historically contingent economic system which leaves millions of people without access to healthcare?
B) Use your laundered dirty money in other addresses to pump the token on uniswap (or any AMM)
C) Sell the token from address in A) back into the Uniswap liquidity pool at a massive profit, enjoy the profits and reintegrated money. You look like any trader.
D) Bag hold the token in the address from B) and never think about it again and never worry about trying to cash that out. In addition that address can add to the liquidity pool and provide a service to all other traders indefinitely.
E) Laugh at people that are still imagining how difficult it is to launder money on public ledgers. Blockchain detectives on their wild goose chase looking at the wrong addresses.
Do this all over time, and not immediately pumping a token with the laundered money.
Sure, I’ll probably get more scrutiny after writing this but you won’t. I really hate chilled speech and people having dumb ideas because the should-be-obvious reality is never talked about. The point is that the trader behavior is indistinguishable from others, and there are no financial intermediaries on permissionless AMMs to flag anything.
(This style of intentionally introducing a pricing error and arbitraging it yourself happens for real and is not always particularly profitable. You can read about the foreign exchange fixing antitrust shenanigans. Some traders thought they were being very clever, and, according to Matt Levine, made relatively small amounts of money and ended up getting seriously smacked down. The feds and the courts may be slow, but they’re not dumb.)
This all seems very abstract, but, when you try to spend what you think were carefully laundered ransomware gains on a nice beach in France or Florida and Interpol or the FBI arrests you, the resulting trial and prison time will be considerably less abstract. :)
Sounds like a great benefit for the government