Maybe they'll get addicted to reading. Society will not crumble, and no children will be harmed.
Maybe they'll get addicted to reading. Society will not crumble, and no children will be harmed.
If your theory was true, we'd have seen historically massive upticks in violence from videogames. It is yet to materialise. This is an era of unusual peace.
In contrast, pornography (visual or textual) is quite similar to its real-world counterpart.
A cursory look around online erotic roleplayers, online stories, the manga/doujinshi sold in huge numbers every year in Japan at Comiket, or even the plots of mainstream porn will quickly disabuse you of this notion. I'm also not convinced on the 'no real comparison' for video games. I'm reminded of the fact that the US Army recruits first-person shooter players, and that video games can show a rise in aggression in lab settings, similar to real sports do.
Even if they were all that different, you'd still have to specify in which specific ways, and the extent of those ways, the difference between the two entertainments is relevant to your argument.
We have seen historically massive upticks in child abuse material [1], caused by two inventions: the internet and smartphones with cameras, and there's a strong case made that it reflects an actual, large, increase in child sexual abuse.
I don't have a specific article to link to, but Gabriel Dance discusses in a podcast [2] how many paedophiles are gradually indoctrinated by communities; they are made, not born.
[1] https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2019/09/28/us/child-sex-... Warning: extremely distressing descriptions.
[2] https://samharris.org/podcasts/213-worst-epidemic/ Warning: ditto, though not as bad.
But what is clearly new is that now people are encouraged to abuse children because they can take a video, share it, sell it, gloat about it, trade it to get access to more material.
Additionally, sharing imagery of abuse further harms the victims. For example, in that podcast it was mentioned that some victims receive a notification every time images of their abuse come up in a court case!
[3] https://www.nytimes.com/2020/02/07/us/online-child-sexual-ab... No warning needed, no descriptions of abuse. (Sorry, paywall. Disable JS.)
I would like to hear that strong case. I cannot find the data right now, but I have heard the rate of child sexual abuse cases has fallen since the internet's debut. A possible reason (if the rate has fallen) being that pedophiles, who know they will be severely punished if caught abusing a child, now have easy access to existing material. They don't have to exploit or abuse children around them.
We don't have a guaranteed way to keep somebody from developing pedophilia, so we shouldn't ban fictional material that isn't related to actual exploitation or abuse. Images, videos, or even writing based on real events need to be caught (with the usual caveat of non-pornographic use, like a victim's memoire or a therapist's training materials).
Again, I'm still looking for hard data on the rates of child sexual abuse.
According to it, US federal attorneys dealt with 568 suspects of child sex abuse in 1994, and 601 in 2006. The chart shows the count remained steady-ish between those years. If we keep in mind that the US population was increasing, that means the rate of child sexual abusers being investigated has gone down.
Over that time period, the rate of people investigated for child pornography drastically increased. This evidence does not support a casual relationship.
After all, that largest known organization tied to sexual exploitation of children is.... the catholic church. And the abuse scandal goes back much farther than even the invention of the internet itself.
So we can't heap the blame on the internet. If anything, the internet is bringing these issues to light, when before they were shrouded in secrecy. Consider the alternative interpretation of the NYT report.
If only 3000 images were reported in 1998, but there were still thousands of cases in the US alone, then the internet has actually made it easier to investigate and find the criminals.
If you think that's evidence against the theory, you're committing a common statistical error. The internet could spawn a million new pedophiles that all have multiple victims, and the catholic church would still retain the title, because even though it may be the largest offender, that doesn't necessarily mean anything with regard to total offenders, or where they come from.
You actually want to look at actual crime statistics.
> between 1993 and 2005, the number of sexually abused children dropped 38 percent, while number of children who experienced physical abuse fell by 15 percent and those who were emotionally abused declined by 27 percent. [1]
People want to blame pornography and the internet for problems that existed before the internet even existed. And the numbers and facts show the exact opposite: crimes are going down.
[1] https://www.livescience.com/17285-child-sexual-abuse-numbers...
> Increase of photos of children on the internet just means that more people are using the internet.
That's too strong an assertion. It doesn't "just" mean anything, it indicates some relationship, not necessarily a complete explanation.
Personally, I don't know whether I think one way or the other on this, but I don't think it's nearly as cut and dry as people are presenting it. As I understand it, sexual behavior does not always follow the same patterns as other behavior, and people rushing to immediately assume it is or isn't related should probably step back and think a bit more critically, and gather a bit more verified information that directly applies.
To me, the fact that so many people are rushing in with arguments that I see as tenuous, if not outright fallacious, points towards an emotional response by people rather than a rational response. Given the subject matter, and that if the theory presented is true it's purely negative for all involved, as both the pedophiles created (or made worse) by exposure as well as their potential victims are worse off, it deserves some respect in how it is responded to. If it's false, it deserves to be clearly and obviously indicated as such with evidence, and if it's NOT, then we should really examine what that means.
I don't think that should be up to 'us' (non-pedophiles) to decide. Arguably, perhaps the Internet doesn't 'create' pedophiles as much as it may help people understand that they are pedophiles, and that society's shaming of them (which, yes, does lead to worse psychological outcomes and increased stress for the afflicted person) has negatively impacted them and forced them to keep quiet about their sexuality. This stigma even prevents them from seeing mental health care providers, for fear that therapists will incorrectly (and perhaps even illegally) report them.
I have no opinion that fiction can impact pedophiles and inflame their desires, but I do not think that is a good enough reason to do away with fiction (to make the publisher liable) - the degrees of separation are too high for me to see illegalising fiction as a reasonable and just measure. The idea that someone can be thrown in prison for the mere risk of the following circumstances coalescing:
* Creating material that might appeal to some pedophiles
* If those pedophiles find the material
* If it hits on the appropriate themes to inflame desires (e.g. is it straight fiction? Gay fiction? Is the subject in the fiction the right age? The right appearance?)
* If those 'inflamed desires' are processed by the pedophile's brain to relate to the real world, forming a plan of action (let's call this real-desire)
* If that real-desire faces no moral or practical impediment to its execution
* If the pedophile's impulse control is low enough to execute the real-desire
This is an extremely tenuous chain of events, each one relying on the previous event - and most of this chain of events is squarely in the court of the pedophile/potential child abuser, not the author of the fiction, who still merely creates the risk of this chain of events occurring. This is complicated by the fact that we have no idea how many non-offending pedophiles there are, and we know that most child sexual abuse is not perpetrated by strangers, but by family members (i.e. there is a specific target; this is not usually how people relate to porn), and a large portion of that sexual abuse is not even perpetrated by pedophiles.
The best tactic to prevent child sexual abuse is to stop assuming all pedophiles are potential rapists, and to stop assuming that the people who consume fiction necessarily find fictional desires reflected in their actual psychology (or vice versa). See Patrick Galbraith on this topic.
I meant, specifically, if society will punish you severely for behaving a certain way, and if behaving that way also causes severe negative outcomes for others, then something that causes people to develop desire for and possibly actual behavior in that way is purely negative for everyone involved, including society, the person that develops the desire and/or behavior, and the people that behavior affects.
As a simple extreme theoretical variation, if looking at specific shade of color that was not natural or common caused people that viewed it to enter a trance-like state where they murdered others, we would say "holy shit, get rid of that color everywhere. People are being murdered, and the murderers are victims too!"
And I'm not saying I believe the statement about material creating pedophiles either, but given the importance of the outcome, it's definitely something we should pay attention to and try to find the truth about. That truth might be that it's easily proven false, or that it's obviously true, or that it's some weird complicated combination thereof, but the I think it's obvious that the correct case is not to say "naw, it's the same as videogame violence, and we've all come to the conclusion that that's bunk, so this is bunk, case closed." There are real reasons why it might be different than violence, or that the statistics that make one acceptable don't work out the same way for the other.
> The best tactic to prevent child sexual abuse is to stop assuming all pedophiles are potential rapists
And I'm not assuming that. But I am working under that assumption that the same person will have more problems with pedophile leanings/preferences than one without, because as a society we've decided to make that so. Looking at fictional images can get you arrested. Having a desire to look at images like this is a negative outcome for that person in a societal and legally sense (and possibly in a mental health sense as being told that you have something wrong with you can be debilitating, I'm sure), compared to not having that desire, and this is about creating that desire in an individual.
To me, this means that we should distigmatize pedophilia in a very careful way - that is, to make it clear that to act on that desire in the real world is a violation of consent. At the moment, the only thing we've done as a society is to act as though these desires are exceedingly rare, that those desires posses the holder to act impulsively (while, simultaneously, erecting the idea of the plotting and cunning pedophile), and that without any more research, that fiction may lead to certain conclusions in that person's mind.
The reason why video game violence is brought up so much is for two reasons; firstly, because we don't have solid evidence on the effects of how (a) pedophiles understand such media (b) previously-offending pedophiles understand such media (c) how non-pedophiles but interested parties understand such media (d) how non-pedophiles and non-interest parties understand such media. For (a), the closest evidence we have (as far as I know) is (b). For (c), we have some ethnographic evidence from Japan that consumers of such fiction draw a sharp distinction between the "2D" and "3D" worlds. For (d) we only have some evidence that ordinary people are not conditioned to associate sexual descriptions to scantily-clad, real, underage children. Secondly, it's brought up because video games (and by extension horror movies, and even adult pornography) have exposed the idea that desires for what is seen may not leave the hypothesized impact on the viewer. What was previously thought of as obvious by a succession of moral panics around violent movies and later video games has been shown to be nothing more than that.
Is more research required? Absolutely - I don't think anyone can argue with that. However, research which focuses on pedophilic orientations only through the lens of convicted offenders (i.e. those who have sexually abused children, or accessed real world child pornography) does not do the topic justice. I think it's fair to say that this is comparable to similar situations - not to say that this comparison is binding or solid evidence, only a hint in the direction of a conclusion - of how people enjoy simulated rape pornography, and how people enjoy fantastical pornography. For those studies, at least, we are able to access the adult-attraction equivalents of group (c) and (d).
I'm in a strange position myself in this debate - I don't believe that moralism is the way forward, but I also (and I think along with you) don't believe that non-moral solutions can work well in our current society. The question is, for me, to what extent a pedophile can recognize that child abuse is wrong, but still express themselves sexually, to be comfortable with their sexuality.
Still, I think my point still stands. To imprison a fiction author on a tenuous basis is wrong, because it invoves the notion of collective responsibility, the notion that the author has contributed to an 'atmosphere' is by that measure guilty. The fact that many other (pedophiles with no desire to offend, non-pedophiles with no desire to offend) enjoy the material, and can be reasonably expected to be the primary audience of the material is enough to even absolve the creator of the material morally - never mind legally.
On the weight of what I see as the available evidence, analogous (video games, other forms of pornography, kink communities) or otherwise (studies of fictional CSEM fans in Japan), the presumption should be in favour of non-regulation, especially given the stasticts on who child sexual abusers are in reality.
See my reply down-thread.
I also don't think this would be easy to study at all. Furries might be a good candidate population to study.
As it is, it looks like an pedophilia is a unasked for mental state spread out over the population at random.
But my view would be people don't choose to be pedophiles. I believe it's fairly well established that childhood sexual abuse correlates to adulthood pedophilia. Likewise nobody is born a furry, and, while being a furry doesn't demand sexual interest, exposure to sexualized furry content probably tilts some people in that direction over time.
I do think its kind of fucked up to not differentiate between people who are active child abusers and people who recognizing they're attracted to children but find it morally wrong and desire help.