Reaper won me over back in the day with its 3.5mb binary download size and awesome licensing model. Even when it was version 2 it could run more VST instruments, with smaller buffers (lower latency & fewer dropouts), than Nuendo, Cubase, Samplitude, Cakewalk, or Logic. And it was way better at tracking, at less than 1/100th of the download size, with actual multiplatform support.
Made me a Justin Frankel fanboy for life. It's only gotten better and better since.