So you are saying that if you hire them, they will learn everything about your business and then sell it to the next client?
It's still less of an issue of a competitor poaching your key people. And by not hiring consultants, you do risk getting behind on a lot of practices.
Undeserved respect for brands is where the problem is, in my opinion.
Consulting deals are sold on the golf course, noone at that level cares what actually happens as long as the slides produced justify what they wanted to do anyway. Individual consultants just go through the motions to make it look semi-plausible.