Strangely, there was no mention of it, aside from “relentless anxiety and depression, eating disorders, exercise addiction, obsessive-compulsive tendencies.” All of these are common comorbidities in bipolar individuals.
Strangely, there was no mention of it, aside from “relentless anxiety and depression, eating disorders, exercise addiction, obsessive-compulsive tendencies.” All of these are common comorbidities in bipolar individuals.
The model is not reality especially so for the DSM, which was built in a medically theraputic context. And should be taken as such.
Hard disagree, the experience of somone with bipolar is a lot different than somone who's schizophrenic or only has major depression or generalized anxiety. Mania and the specific difficulties it causes for psychosis are radically different than what the others have to deal with and so is the general unpredictability of life (for planning and commitment purposes) and especially the types of effects it has on relationships. Each of the disorders have totally different profiles subjectively and objectively and different things they have to deal with. It's definitely not just a "statistical artefact" dispite the possibility of multiple diseases causing the same symptom clusters.
[1] https://www.webmd.com/bipolar-disorder/news/20100601/bipolar...
Viewed differently, this speaks to the extreme dangers of psychiatric drugs. They should be a tool (vital!) of last resort but are often used as a frontline therapy.
Fundamentally, anything that modulates the brain should be used with extreme caution. Although the brain is remarkably resilient, sometimes drug-induced changes or side effects can be permanent.
For some, this may come as relief, yet for others, they may find that the solution was worse than the problem. As they say, caveat emptor.
Had major brain fog problems. But was generally happy and good natured.
Spent years seeking help, at every stage was told it was depression.
Turned out it was a horrible disease that was slowing killing me.
I imagine a lot of “depressed” people have an underlying chronic condition that isn’t being addressed.
Make a list every symptom, and what affects your symptoms. Take it to every kind of specialist. Then keep repeating. Take an advocate. I would explain stuff, could see they had mentally written me off. The wife would start bawling. This would wake them up, and they would dig further.
A neuro-ophthalmologist was reading my list. Looked up and declared I had Sjogrens. He was right. Now he missed the clotting disorder.
Then have a clot in your lungs. Then you get taken seriously. That’s when they found factor 5 Leiden.
So between the two my body and mind were trashed.
That theory has largely failed as we can't even really agree which groups of symptoms make which diseases. Hence the constant changes to systems like the DSM.
Full disclosure, I may be bias and I'm also an example: I have Major Mood Disorder. I used to have Severe Clinical Depression. Before that, I had Treatment Resistant Depression. Before that it was just Clinical Monopolar Depression (It's still called monopolar sometimes to differentiate it from Bipolar). My symptoms haven't changed. Nor has the treatments offered. But in the last 10y we've repeatedly renamed, recategorised, reshuffled etc just common depression. God knows what it's like in more complex, less common symptom sets...
The BBCs Life Scientific podcast discusses this very question in this episode if you're interested:
https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/m000sj7c
The wider series is also very good imho.
I think we’ve been incredibly lucky to have the fields of psychology and psychiatry to fill the medical role, especially when the quantitative gaps in our understanding of the brain seem to be widening.
[1] https://bigthink.com/paul-ratner/our-brains-think-in-11-dime...
Modern fluid dynamics cannot adequately explain turbulence. Richard Feynman has described turbulence as the most important unsolved problem in classical physics.[1] We don’t dismiss fluid dynamics because turbulence is ill-defined, and we also don’t deny that turbulence exists just because we lack a thorough mathematical understanding of it.
This is analogous to psychology/psychiatry and mental illnesses. If we had magical brain oscilloscopes that we could hook up to visualize every mental disorder, we’d use them. Until those exist, we must rely on qualitative and statistical approaches to provide treatment.
A unipolar depression is very different from a bipolar depression in many regards. E.g. likeliness to eat less vs. likeliness to eat more.
And a unipolar depression can possibly be treated and then be gone. (If the treatment works out.) If one has bipolar disorder, it won’t go away. One has to live with it the the whole life.
I havent finished reading the article yet but this really struck me as narcissism with some othee commorbidities that you mention.
What makes you think of BD?