>you either do something, or you don’t. There is simply no middle ground.
Only in the narrowest sense.
Another valid response is "you can't do this as-is, but if you make changes X, Y and Z then you can." Or "do more experiments with captive populations first." Or "do this in an area where it's less likely to cause unexpected side effects (eg an unpopulated island somewhere)" Or "use a different set of genes or tweaks"
It's pretty rare that the _only_ possible choices are to do this _one exact thing_, or do nothing at all.