Make Love, Not Flamewars
bitquabit.com
bitquabit.com
Maybe there is a correlation between developers and math? Since I'm guessing many developers might have a CS background that involves a lot of Math, Statistics, Physics, and of course Programming. These subjects require people to answer things correctly hence subconsciously create a habit of being "right".
Obviously, learning new things is much more efficient to keep a job :)
Instead of talking about why you are better than the other guy, let’s focus purely on why your system of choice rocks. That’s it.
Nice diagnosis; useless solution. Tool quality is relative. Fast, easy, safe, these are relative terms. Take me back to 1995, and CVS would be my best friend. Repositories rarely get corrupted, and when they do, they're easy to fix! For 1995 values of "rarely" and "easy", at least. Standards are different now because better competitors have emerged.
Applies to all languages and software.
But yeah, the immaturity with using fallacies (especially ad hominem) to argue puts me off and it doesn't help with the general community votes for it.
Some links for those who wish to know how to debate like an intellectual:
""" After he has said, "I understand but I disagree," he can make the following remarks to the author: (1) "You are uninformed"; (2) "You Are misinformed"; (3) "You are illogical - your reasoning is not cogent"; (4) "Your analysis is incomplete." """
http://books.google.com/books?id=Z5PpkQadm5EC&lpg=PA154&...
With this in mind, I think saying "I love mercurial" without at least referencing git, the more popular DCVS, will be less convincing since anyone can say, "Your analysis is incomplete - haven't you tried the most popular DCVS?"
Debating a topic is supposed to enrich us on that subject. I have changed my opinion on things before, based on Slashdot comments (this was way back), and now based on HN comments.
Of course, there is also the need to portray ourselves as clever. That's the real driver for flamewars: sophistry.
But saying "I love X" does nothing for either cause. People interested in rational decision-making are not engaged; trolls are not discouraged; and newbies are not educated on how to argue better.
(edit: fixed a run-on sentence)
Flame wars are the most virulent when the enemy is extremely close to your position but doesn't take it. Emacs and VIM, essentially the same. Mercurial and GIT, again, the same. If the differences are too far apart the whole argument becomes, meh.
meh.
</troll>
"These questions matter. And they’ve been answered, very eloquently, many times."
I've used CVS, svn, bzr, and git - I'm still a newbie on those last two and therefore persuadable - so where do I read these Hg answers? Seriously, I'm not doubting that they exist, but I'm getting the impression that google results will be polluted, and I'm not sure even the most beatific tweet stream is going to pull me in; but I will peruse the tweet recommended http://hginit.com/
Seriously, where are the issues carefully explained and addressed?
FWIW I love hg and android.
You didn't explain why.
This is only true in the open source world and then only in one corner of it. Subversion is still, by far, the most used version control system in the enterprise.
And why should someone have to argue why they aren't using git? If he loves Mercurial, great! He doesn't have to explain why he doesn't use every other version control system in existence.
That's the point. When you say why you love Hg without saying why you aren't using git, you aren't arguing. The author isn't explaining how to argue more civilly, he's explaining how to make a perfectly valid statement without getting into an argument.
Example: I love riding a hard tail MTB. Most riders will ask why I don't want full suspension. But I'm not arguing about why a hard tail is better. I'm explaining that I love riding a hard tail.
People can't help themselves. They want to defend their choices, even when their choices aren't under scrutiny. They will follow up with a fallacy or two and they start arguing from positions that are so ludicrous that even with the best initial intentions you forget to point out the fallacies they must obviously have committed to arrive at their starting point and just start refuting them. That way, they suck you in.
Only if there are sufficiently many people in a community resistant to this kind of trolling, pointing it out to each other and refraining from feeding the trolls, only then can sensible discussion come about. But it's hard not to get sucked in. It reminds me of David Foster Wallace's speech about being aware of the water that you are in: it's hard work and requires an amount of self-awareness that can be exhausting.
Nobody forces you to pander to these people's neuroses. You are not the troll whisperer. This over here is my favourite interview question. That over there is my favourite line of Ruby code. This is my favourite book. I wrote blog posts about all of these subjects and attracted exactly the responses you describe. But I was happiest when I ignored the people who had an agenda of arguing about their favourite interview question or their favoruite line of code or their favourite book.
Nobody compels you to play their game. So don't.
But someone getting so invested in what they think that a stranger believes, such that they have to start a flame war? And expecting that I have some sort of obligation to their egocentricity such that I must respond to their questions?
Well, I'm not a psychologist, so the odds are strongly against this being clinically neurotic. But it isn't for me, and I don't feel a compulsion to play along.
p.s. Again, this isn't about people's right to believe what they want to believe. I'm ok with people believing I'm an idiot. They may be right! But what I'm talking about is whether I have to respond. I don't. I also don't have to worry about it when I write such that I try to deflect criticism or protect my reputation.
- The information is often factually wrong. Letting wrong information go uncorrected will lead to that information spreading and that doesn't seem like a good thing to me.
- It often doesn't seem to be the intention of people to troll and it is hard to suppress the urge to teach. It would be awesome if you could get more people to intentionally not-troll.
The first may be an instance of http://xkcd.com/386/ and the second may be a case of vanity (thinking you can change people), but just ignoring people doesn't improve things either, so shouldn't you at least try?
Unfortunately, attempting to address both these points simultaneously seems a recipe for disaster and just results in 'feeding the troll'.
Several weeks ago, Daring Fireball featured a link to an exchange between Ian Fleming and a man who wrote him offering suggestions (and a critique of James Bond's current) pistol selection. In a comment here at HN, I believe, someone noted the civility, the maturity of the exchange.
I thought about that comment, and I decided that I was going to try to restrain myself and make comments that a hypothetical adult might make.
HN is part of a problem, and that problem is what I'll call the cable news-ification of everything. No, not the Fox News-ification, but the cable news-ification, because the premise of all these channels is that when something happens, the most important thing is to have an opinion about what happened, and to broadcast and debate that opinion as vigorously as possible.
Am I missing something, or how can one possibly see a list of downvoters for a given comment?
I've (mistakenly) assumed that you need to see the list of downvoters to make a statement such as edw's, whereas I now see how, having information you and edw provided, you can just infer this statement.
A lesson to learn for me here :).
If I read a post explaining a mercurial workflow that looked easier then what I do now I might check it out. Yeah you read correctly, I didn't even install mercurial. I just moved from svn to git once rails and most gems did. I guess I am not the only one so there are people youcould convince.