Also things like
>adding only hooks for you means that all the other terminals get no benefit.
Makes me quite concerned since these hooks weren't just for termite, as evidenced by tilix showing interest in this patch set.
>Implementing this in VTE would mean ruling out having any flexibility in the terminal using the library. [...] an implementation inside VTE won't satisfy the use case.
I think that the termite developer explained very clearly why the approach suggested by the VTE maintainer wouldn't actually solve the problem they were having, and the maintainer responded with a simple "wontfix" and no more discussion.
This is kind of the thing we're talking about. One project said they needed this, another project said they'd also appreciate this feature, and instead of discussing how to make this work, setting clear requirements and the like, it took 2 years to respond to the first patch submission and then the issue was just randomly closed in the middle of a discussion.
If you are interested to work on this patch, it wouldn't hurt to ask the maintainer for clarification.
>as evidenced by tilix showing interest in this patch set.
That's two of them, there are other terminals that use VTE.
>I think that the termite developer explained very clearly why the approach suggested by the VTE maintainer wouldn't actually solve the problem they were having
I don't think so, the termite developer is making that assumption before the new patch was even completed. Additional options could be added with the suggested approach.
>Additional options could be added with the suggested approach.
doesn't make any sense when the maintainer closed the ticket with "wontfix" in the middle of the discussion? Are we both reading the same thread? It seems like we're disagreeing about some fundamental facts here, but actually reading the ticket makes the facts pretty clear?