Another Man’s DNA Is Found on Murder Weapon Years After Execution
nytimes.com
nytimes.com
Also consider the US has the highest incarceration rate on the planet except Seychelles, and the prison population demographics are strongly skewed towards poor, mentally-disabled who are reasonably incompetent to make legal decisions, minorities, and men.
Louisiana has 1.4% (2.5% or 1 in 40 men) of all of their citizens behind bars. Texas has 1.2%.
But it would not be any kind of "gotcha" anyway.
A remediable error is different from an irrecoverable error.
IMHO, it's probably worse than execution to subject someone to life imprisonment in a supermax like ADX Florence.
(Not trolling: I actually believe this.)
What does that even mean?
Yes, in general, but even more particularly in a system featuring either some degree of direct democracy or supermajority requirements and/or appointed decision makers whose term extends beyond the elected officials that appointed them so effects of past control extend beyond an election loss or separation of powers where there is no single “the election” that determines current control of government (the US, at the federal level, has the last two, and most US states have all three.)
As the saying goes, better 100 guilty persons should go free than 1 innocent should suffer.
I am fiercely opposed to the death penalty, and this example goes a long way towards conveying why.
It is better that ten guilty persons escape than that one innocent suffer.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blackstone%27s_ratio
The death penalty stoops to the level of violent offenders and state processes that can never get convictions perfectly correct all of the time to be moral and ethical. There is no "undo" button on state-sanctioned murder, needle or drone strike.